The French motorbiker mag Moto-Journal has done an extensive test of heavy dual-purpose bikes (called Trials here).
The results:
1. BMW R1150GS 446 points out of 560 max
2. Triumph Tiger 440
3. Aprillia Caponord 437
4. Honda Varadero 412
The GS was found best in class on handling, "life on board" and for the passenger. It was last on the engine section, but with a mention that despite a weaker engine, it could handle off-road and normal road conditions better than others. It also lost out on the financial section, no surprise there.
In the "handling" section, it crushed all competition in all areas.
The results:
1. BMW R1150GS 446 points out of 560 max
2. Triumph Tiger 440
3. Aprillia Caponord 437
4. Honda Varadero 412
The GS was found best in class on handling, "life on board" and for the passenger. It was last on the engine section, but with a mention that despite a weaker engine, it could handle off-road and normal road conditions better than others. It also lost out on the financial section, no surprise there.
In the "handling" section, it crushed all competition in all areas.