Please respond if you've NOT had a 1200GS/GSA fuel pump controller failure

camel_landy

camel_landy

Well-known member
UKGSer Subscriber
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
5,086
Reaction score
532
Location
Swansea & Gloucestershire
After someone :thedummy and moderated the comments from Wapping & I, I want to add some balance to the fuel pump controller thread.

Please add your name (or details of a friend) if you have NOT had a fuel pump controller failure on a 1200GS or 1200GSA.

- rider name
- bike details (model and year)
- mileage
- typical weather conditions ridden in
- is the bike stored for long periods of time

M
 
:D not had one yet.....
07 GSA it's done around 2500 miles now and used in all weathers most days.....

;)
 
- Antonios Piskopakis
- R 1200 GSA '07
- 15.000 klms
- all weathers
- never stored for more than 4 days
 
Andres Sotos-Castello
R1200GS '05
33,000
All weathers
Riden a minumum of twice a week

I've only got one friend :(

But he has got a GS :)

Simon
R1200GS ADV '06
18,000
All weathers
Not enough :thumb


Andres
 
Charlie Miller
'04 1200 GS
16,000 miles (owned for two years)
All weathers but most recently p*ssing rain mostly
Stored for up to a month at a time
 
- Matt Parkinson
- '04 1200GS
- 20,000
- All weathers
- Used daily
 
camel_landy said:
After someone :thedummy and moderated the comments from Wapping & I, I want to add some balance to the fuel pump controller thread.
Click to expand...
Why?

Balance isn't needed.

What's wrong with someone collating information about a poorly designed part? And who the poorly designed part has affected?

BTW my fuel pump controller hasn't failed. Yet.

But I'm on my fourth set of forks on my HP and thinking of starting a similar thread regarding HP fork failure. I've spoken to BM about it and of course they deny there's a problem, and so it would be nice to give them some factual evidence of other failures rather than just hearsay.
 
Spout said:
What's wrong with someone collating information about a poorly designed part? And who the poorly designed part has affected?
Click to expand...

...but how 'poorly designed' is that 'poorly designed' part. Does it affect 100% of bikes, 10%, 0.001%??

There's nothing wrong with Tim's thread, however he is just focusing on the negative aspects. I have done the same but I'm focusing on the positive to give it some balance as I feel strongly about putting threads like this into context.

M
 
BMW Motorrad celebrated an impressive record on 27 July 2007 as the 100,000th R 1200 GS rolled off the production line in Berlin, Germany. Since the introduction of the all-new, lighter and more powerful R 1200 GS in 2004, a staggering 84,373 units have been built, plus an additional 15,627 of its model variant, the R 1200 GS Adventure.
Click to expand...

Well I recon a lot of these haven't ;)
 
Spout said:
Why?

Balance isn't needed.

What's wrong with someone collating information about a poorly designed part? And who the poorly designed part has affected?

......


so it would be nice to give them some factual evidence of other failures rather than just hearsay.
Click to expand...

Do you really think they dont already have the factual evidence?
 
camel_landy said:
...but how 'poorly designed' is that 'poorly designed' part. Does it affect 100% of bikes, 10%, 0.001%??

There's nothing wrong with Tim's thread, however he is just focusing on the negative aspects. I have done the same but I'm focusing on the positive to give it some balance as I feel strongly about putting threads like this into context.

M
Click to expand...

I think it's you who is being positively negative.

Why try to be a smart-arse when someone is trying, I imagine, to gather information which may in the long-run benifit us all?:nenau
 
harry said:
I think it's you who is being positively negative.

Why try to be a smart-arse when someone is trying, I imagine, to gather information which may in the long-run benifit us all?:nenau
Click to expand...

Couldn't have said it better myself. :thumb2

BTW, there's 10 'everything's fine' posts on this thread and >50 reports of failures on the other... :augie

Tim
 
Ed McCarthy
07 GSA
21000km
Irish Weather, so WET
Bike used every day, stored in a shed
 
Ian R
Male
2002 1150GS
32,000 miles
ridden every couple of days
Favourite colour : Black
Dogs Name : Benjy
Cats Name : Deceased
Rabbits Name : Cat Killer
Living with Partner
Owner / occupier
2 Cars
3 Visa Cards
Gym Membership
Likes : Bikes, aviation and photography
Dislikes : Intolerance, Mandarin Yellow

Is this the survey to win the weekend for 2 in Barcelona :nenau
 
Tim Cullis said:
BTW, there's 10 'everything's fine' posts on this thread and >50 reports of failures on the other...
Click to expand...

Which is precisely the point I was making...

By using the current figures, the fuel pump failure rate is at >80%. Without having that balance, we wouldn't know.

I also added the extra questions to see if the riding conditions & storage had an affect on the problem (e.g. riding in rain & storing for extended periods of time).

I'm not 'dissing' your thread but I do think you should put it into context.

M
 
Nippy Normans supply Touratech, Wunderlich, Desert Fox and many other makes of accessories.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Please respond if you're NOT GOING TO HAVE A 1200GS FPS FAILURE
2 3
Replies
44
Views
5,923
SMB
SMB
Tim Cullis
The sorry saga of 1200GS/GSA fuel pump controller failures (410 so far)
18 19 20
Replies
391
Views
156,237
Bendy toy


Back
Top Bottom