Band of Brothers Tour

Bury_Dave

Registered user
Joined
Sep 7, 2010
Messages
1,251
Reaction score
1
Location
Suffolk, England
Thought I'd recommend a book I'm reading

http://www.amazon.com/Toccoa-Eagles...4791/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1327067194&sr=8-1

It's a Septic's research to follow much more prescisely than the serial, the route taken by Easy Co. He walks the locations and gives very good descriptions of the battles and sites and adds much more to the bones of the story. He also has information and interviews regarding many who were not mentioned in the series but who were as, if not more, pivotal characters that the ones portrayed. There are two long chapters too on what the ones you know and the others did post WW2 - for example that 'Blithe' survived the war (contrary to the series saying he died in 1948) and stayed in the Airborne and made over 600 jumps before a premature death in 1967(?)

It's very good. Covering lots more than the rather bitty (but still excellently done) BoB serial.

The serial compressed some events into ones where they didn't occur . For example, Easy fought equally hard in other towns during the Bulge battles after Foye.

I've never been 100% comfortable that Winters made contact with Ambrose to get the book written and I am no fan of Ambrose with all his errors in his books and an unwillingness to correct them, his plagiarism and his hatred of all things British (apart from the OBLI Pegasus landing), however, I see Easy Co as symbolic of all the men who fought rather than beign the best of the best as they have been labelled.

Regardless, it is a very good book and with a map and goole earth, you can really get a feel for what happened and to whom and where.

I am tempted to use this and the 'In The Footsteps of Band of Brothers' book to set out a Garmin route and try it out when i go on tour in May/June this year. If it works well, I'll do a trip report and make the route available.

Dave
 
..... I am tempted to use this and the 'In The Footsteps of Band of Brothers' book to set out a Garmin route and try it out when i go on tour in May/June this year. If it works well, I'll do a trip report and make the route available.
Brilliant. :clap
 
Brilliant. :clap

don't think I'd go quite that far ! ;)

I already have some sections of routes that cover the Hurtgen and Reichswald forests, the fighting around Berlin and general points of interest for WW2 (bit of an anorak ..... :toungincheek ). They might all link in in some way but the general route of Easy lends itself to a tour from Upottery to Nijmegen and on to Bavaria via the Alsace going out and maybe back via Berlin and the forests ........... Hell, maybe I should do a WW2 battlefields 'book' of my own on DVD with chapters with links to routes and photos and sub-histories ....... ;)
 
I tried to follow parts of the route on my way to Berlin a few years ago.

I think I got it right, but I wish a book like this had been around then. Oh well, it's an excuse to do another trip. :D
 
I am tempted to use this and the 'In The Footsteps of Band of Brothers' book to set out a Garmin route and try it out when i go on tour in May/June this year. If it works well, I'll do a trip report and make the route available.

Dave

Its funny that you should mention that...Ive been thinking exactly the same thing. I watch the series over and over and given the current work situation I figure that in the not too distant future I will have plenty of time on my hands :(. I was thinking of starting...well here (Switzerland)...cutting across to Oradour-sur-glane ( Sister lives in that region), then heading up to the the Normandy beaches and following the route of Easy company. Id like to try and fit in the Dambusters raid (Mohn, Eder, Sorpe, Lister & Ennepe) if possible.

Id be interested to know how you get on.
 
Taff, did you make it to the Oder or Seelow Heights or Halbe? Did you do a tour report ?
No and sort of. I'll have a look to see if I can still find a link.

Edit: the only thing I can find was THIS thread I started when I was planning the trip.

I do remember I managed to get to Arnhem, the bridge at Son, then rode onto Eindhoven.
 
Will do. Working on it already.

For those who are BOB fans, here's a link to a military historian's critique of the mini-series.

He is someone who has documented other 101st units and was in contact with Dick Winters before the Ambrose book. He really knows his onions.

He gets a little anoraky over the fact that some of the actors weren't the same height as their real characters (of no real consequence ....) and of technical errors like wrong overseas hats and insignia (again of no consequence and he does that more to get at the actual advisors to the series - particularly Dale Dye) more to ask why, with such a high budget, they couldn't get those small details right.

But its' usefulness is in putting right the actual inaccuracies of real consequence such as the behavior of the mini series individuals against the real people and incidents that didn't actually happen.

He has one page to each episode.

I found it very interesting. Maybe someone else will too.

http://www.101airborneww2.com/bandofbrothers3.html
 
I love that show and all things WW2 :rob lol

Me too Johnny. It's been a lifelong passion of mine as far back as 'Victor' and 'Warlord ' comics. As a kid in East Anglia, I used to cycle to the old airfields in the area - before most had lost their runways. As a teenager, I hitch hiked to France and broke into sections of the Maginot Line before they became museums. And visited the WW1 battlefields. It continued from there.

The book 'Toccoa to the Eagles Nest' does have photos. As the book was self-published, the author didn't have the funds to include more than a few in B&W. BUT he has a Facebook account which apparently has hundreds of photos of his visits. So I've just created a fb account simply so i can see the photos !

I'll keep you posted :thumb2 Dave
 
I already have some sections of routes that cover the Hurtgen...

An often overlooked battlefield... I took some mates there for a tour back in the winter of 2008. The forest is beautiful and was very haunting...

n514028026_1261267_6825.jpg


...especially when you come across this:

n514028026_1261914_3156.jpg

Memorial to a PFC Robert Cahow, 311th Reg 78th Inf Div, whose skeleton was found over 50 years after the battle in the Hurtgen Forest by a German Ordnance team.

n514028026_1261220_5622.jpg

Taking fire on the Siegfried Line:

n514028026_1261903_263.jpg

Foy from a Bois Jacques Fox Hole... (You might recognise the location from the BoB documentary with Heffron and Guarnere)

n514028026_1261252_2892.jpg

Baugnez, location of the Malmedy massacre.

n514028026_1261259_4666.jpg

n514028026_1261221_5828.jpg

Bastogne Memorial... and from its observation deck.

n514028026_1261305_9420.jpg

Then of course there's the :beer::beer::beer:

If you can visit the area in the winter with a bit of snow I'd reccomend it... The weather really brought the place to life for us. And if you fancy bit of a detour of a German Airborne battlefield check out Fort Eben Emael. BoB was awesome... but don't forget they were one unit of many. If you ever need a guide with PROPER local knowledge of the Bulge area I can reccomend Henri Mignon... and for anything BoB related, especially in Normandy, I reccomend local D-Day Historian Paul Woodadge.

:beerjug:
 
Ambroses book is littered with problems. If you want a good read I suggest
Beyond Band of Brothers (Dick Winters)
Easy Company Soldier (Don Malarkey)
Call of Duty * Lyn "Buck" Compton

Thee is also Brothers in Battle best of Friends by Wild Bill and Babe.

My collection of the above are signed by the Authors (except Dick) and a number of other Easy Co veterans.

If in St Mere Eglise the B&B right on the square is very very good and the Airborne Museum is well worth a visit,


Sounds like a great trip.
 
Christ, this is spooky. Have BoB box set which i`ve just been watching again, afterwards think of a tour and here is a link !
Ordered the book ,thanks for the title (Amazon uk ) to read, will follow this link with interest.
Cheers Stu.
 
thanks for that, ordered the book as well, as i have time on my hands after coming out of hospital :( Must watch the dvds again, will spur me on for a tour hopefully in the future
 
I'm just about to dig out the box set again... we're off to Normandy on 10th June for a stay at Maison Laudeire :Motomartin

Looking forward to seeing some of the stuff in the area, so this is interesting stuff :beerjug:
 
Bury Dave, did you ever get the chance to do the route out?

I've got all the main and many of the secondary locations as waypoints and got references to which page on which book covers the action or background.

What I am trying to do now is link all of that into a series of nice rides between them that might also include some other WW2 points of interest.

Then to get a handle on the mileage and time needed, plus potential detours - Easy weren't the only unit in WW2 ;-)

It's not a small task !

Dave
 


Back
Top Bottom