A year on.
Next month I will have had the 1190R a year, here are a few observations coming back from a 1200 mile round trip to Brittany I have done for the last 3 years. The previous tours have been on a 2010 GSA.
Wind protection: Ace when it's hot, exposed when it's rains.
Performance: KTM's in a different league, although I miss the engine braking of the boxer.
Fuel consumption: Averaging 11.5 miles a litre, the fuel computer stays at the same mileage for 20/30 miles without dropping, then drops in one go, not ideal.
Comfort: The KTM is comfier than the GSA for me, the sheepskin is ace for longer trips, having used it on both bikes but needed Sargent seats on the GSA aswell.
Stability when laden: The GSA wins here, I never experienced any wobbles whatsoever.
Off road: The KTM is far more predictable, manageable and fun on green lanes, probably an unfair comparison to the GSA but that's what I bought both bikes in mind of.
Reliability: The KTM has been back to the dealers only for recalls, that can't be said for my GSA.
Quality: Pretty equal I'd say, nothing has deteriorated on the KTM, although the GSA still looked new after nearly 4 years with absolutely no corrosion anywhere.
Day to day: The chain drive on the KTM is a negative, it does take up more time to clean and lube and when the spray says non fling they are lying!
Overall the KTM is ticking more of my boxes and I have no intention of swapping it anytime soon, the new GSA is not a forward step for me, the only thing that may be interesting is the new Honda Africa Twin but we will have to wait and see where that will be pitched.