Streetguard 3 replacement Vs new Tourshell

[Wyreflyer]

Bought my SG3 jacket and pants over 3 years ago and they've been great, except they faded badly and were replaced under warranty. The main zip on the jacket has now failed and it turns out it's another known fault. BMW will contribute a good will discount, but based on my original purchase date, so I can get a new SG3 jacket at 50% ie £315.
So do I fork out for yet another SG3 or is the Tourshell a viable replacement, the total cost of the jacket and pants is £710.
I tried on the Tourshell and it's really comfortable and far less restrictive than the SG3, but will it be as good in the winter? I ride for fun all year round but have a Rallye 3 jacket for summer, so thinking more about cold and rainy days.
I'm worried I'm missing something about the Tourshell, why is it so 'cheap' compared to the other BMW suits?

 

[ebbo]

I'm interested in a Tourshell combo for next Spring too, how's it breathability? It's not Gore-Tex, but it is a breathable laminate of some kind

 

[RichieS]

I have the original Tourshell combo and quite simply, layer up underneath with good quality kit such a Ice breaker and Rab. Only small criticism on the original kit is it only has a half zip to connect the 2 together. If the new one has a full zip, i'd say go for it. Never leaked and have been in some shite weather in mine.

 

[ebbo]

I have the original Tourshell combo and quite simply, layer up underneath with good quality kit such a Ice breaker and Rab. Only small criticism on the original kit is it only has a half zip to connect the 2 together. If the new one has a full zip, i'd say go for it. Never leaked and have been in some shite weather in mine.

Thanks Richie, how's it been in hot weather, breathability ok?

 

[Wyreflyer]

Thanks for the info Richie

 

[Stanley Knife]

I am on my second SG3, jacket zip on the first one failed when it was 18 months old,replaced FOC under warranty.

Since then I have been extremely careful with the zip and despite this it is starting to split at the bottom,great jacket but I now avoid wearing it much especially if going for a longer trip as its going to break at some point.

Not really good enough for a £500 plus bit of kit.

 

[Reggie P]

Another vote for the tourshell.

I love mine . It looks good , its light and comfy. The protection is in the right place. (Even the grey "lining jacket" it came with is quite a cool piece of clothing and can be worn off the bike)

It never leaks and breathes well when I'm sweaty.
I can't imagine another jacket / trouser combo fitting quite as well.

 

[Mav]

My SG3 has been great - warm enough with the lining in, always kept me dry (apart from the time I forgot to close the pit zips ) and feels super tough - it feels like it would do well in a tumble.

By contrast, the tourshell doesn't feel as heavyweight - which can be a good and bad thing...

 

[Wapping]

Overall I am happy with my TourShell suit, used as an alternative to my heavier Rukka.

If it has a fault, it's that the left leg can ride up exposing the top of my boot, along with the ingress of water that can bring. Depending on the rider's leg length, bike ridden, boots worn and riding 'style' this may (or may not) be a concern.

Other than that, all is good. Try and buy with confidence

 

[ebbo]

Rght, I'll take a close look at the TourShell, too many busted zips with the StreetGuard 3. My current pants have long legs so keep my boot fully covered when I'm sat on the bike, my mates ride up and can let the rain in (he's well over 6ft) so will pay particular attention to that, cheers

 

[RichieS]

Comfort shell

Thanks Richie, how's it been in hot weather, breathability ok?

I have the original, so no liner, but it has zip vents at the front and back. Toured Spain and France a couple of times this year and temp reaching 28-30 degrees. Open the vents and a suitable thin breathable layer underneath and it was fine. In truth, you are always going to warm in that sort of temperature, but as an allweather, all year suit, its fine. Sure, there are cooler suits, but then you lose out in the cooler weather. Like i say, with proper layering, i reckon it's a bloody good suit.
Hope this helps

 

[Wapping]

Outside of a good electric vest, sensible layering really is the key to staying warm / cool in any motorcycle gear.

By and large I have given up with the liners supplied with may suits, jackets or trousers, preferring to carry layers that can double up when off the bike.

For instance:

A wicking undershirt, T-shirt or leggings. Merino wool is very good but pricey. It doesn't stink; washes and dries quickly. Look after it and it will last for years. The Icebreaker range is good.

A fleece. A thin one from Berghaus and a thicker one from Mountain Equipment, with 'windstopper'. Which one do I take? I look at the likely weather forecast and take an inspired guess. I like the ones that zip completely open, but that's just me. Excellent for the evening, too.

A Lowe Alpine 'shirt'. Again not cheap but mine must be getting on for 10 years old, still going strong with care. It washes out well in a hotel room and will often dry completely overnight.

An EDZ innseshell, very easy to keep in a pocket or tankbag and quick to slip on or off.

If it's really cold, a Rab Neutrino gilet. It packs up small in its own stuff sack. Good for the evening, too. Their microlight version might be good, too.

Between that lot I think have it all just about covered, they have done me for thousands of (reasonably) happy miles

 

[(RIP) Gerry Huxtable]

Zip Replacement

My zip failed so bought a replacement from here

http://www.pennineoutdoor.co.uk/haberdashery/waterproof-zips

fitted by local tailor for £20

cheap fix

cheers

Gerry H.

 

[JohnnyBoxer]

Everybody still pleased with their Tourshell

On my list to check out