What a laugh I had with the 2610

richie

Registered user
Joined
Aug 14, 2003
Messages
9,437
Reaction score
439
Location
Allihies again.. but off to Asia soon....
First time I've used a GPS and I can say that I am far from impressed. Asked it to do the quickest journey home from my bro in law and then I took the shortest. It completely fekked up. It always knew where we were but kept asking me to take ridiculous routes. Tomorrow I'm taking it to the Ardennes for some more fun. Its a shame really as I was hoping it would impress my wife enough to let me get one. But at the rate it went today I think I can kiss the GPS V goodbye.
JEEEZE what a laugh...
I'll let you all know wednesday night how it went...
 
Judging the 2610 after one use

I can't say for sure what happened but perhaps the reason may be that the routing setup preferences have been customized. This can cause the GPS to act as you have described. During a recent trip I mistakenly thought my route settings were "flat", i.e. reset to the defaults. It kept directing me to make turns that I knew weren't correct. Don't give up on it after one try. Its really a fantastic device but it does take some study.
 
Maybe you are right, but it was funny when within one mile of my house it redirected me to the motorway.... It was if it really wanted me to do its original plan....
Tomorrow will be a seventy mile journey to a small ardennes village. I'll see how it goes. Luckily for me I already know the best way to get there...
 
Richie.....K2R might well be spot on with his diagnosis....if the settings on your borrowed unit are saying for example that your speed on a minor road is 10 MPH and on a motorway it's 100 MPH, the unit will try and route you 99 miles on the motorway instead of telling you to do 10 miles on a backroad.....

Check the settings again....my Betty is rarely wrong even if I can beat her using local knowledge...but it does sound like yours has her knickers in a twist :)
 
3rd Rule
Never follow any route if you want to get to your destination in this life.
 
Aw, c'mon guys, they're not that bad!

Seriously, Bill made the most accurate diagnosis with his post (the second post on this thread) - have a look at the routing preferences. If you're not sure, reset them to default. On the SP 26xx series, you can find an option to reset just about any set of preferences to default (without messing up other preferences) by pressing the MENU button a second time when you are on a specific setup page.

The other possibility is there might be a slight error in the cartographic data. I don't mean a visible error, like a road missing, but an attribute error, where the person who was digitizing the map finished work one day at 5:00 PM, went home, came back to work the next morning, started back on a continuation of the same road, but forgot to join the two together.

There are a few of those around - one infamous one is on the 401 expressway in Canada (Canada's most travelled road) - where the GPSR will ask you to get off at an interchange, go 200 yards down the road, make a U-turn, and get back on the same expressway again. Visually, you can't see a break, but there is an "attribute" break in the roadway. It's embarrassing, but NavTech usually gets a lot of feedback about these goofs (they are NavTech problems, not Garmin problems) and they never last for more than one version of the product.

Hey - if it doesn't look like it makes sense, don't follow it. Whenever I am in a totally unfamiliar area, and relying entirely on my motorcycle GPS (or aircraft FMS) for navigation guidance, I always zoom out to a pretty big scale every now and then, just to check for "reasonable-ness". The electronics are very powerful, but they have no critical reasoning - we have to supply that.

PanEuropean
 
Laughs in the UK

Regarding Mr Pan's last post if you want to have a real laugh in the UK have a look at the M6 Toll road. It is there on CN V6 but classed as a cart track by the time it takes you to drive down it. Also it doesn't join onto anything at the eastern / southern end!
 
"but classed as a cart track... "

Maybe they did the classification based on the condition of the surface of the roadway?

PanEuropean
 
PanEuropean said:
There are a few of those around - one infamous one is on the 401 expressway in Canada (Canada's most travelled road) - where the GPSR will ask you to get off at an interchange, go 200 yards down the road, make a U-turn, and get back on the same expressway again. Visually, you can't see a break, but there is an "attribute" break in the roadway. It's embarrassing, but NavTech usually gets a lot of feedback about these goofs (they are NavTech problems, not Garmin problems) and they never last for more than one version of the product.


PanEuropean [/B]

Pan,

On my trip up the M42 / A42 (UK) at the weekend - my 2610 wanted me to get off, go round the roundabout, and re-join on EVERY junction on the way up, and EVERY junction on the way back. I can't believe this fits in with your explanation above - surely this must be a Garmin software bug?
 
Roland Butter said:
Pan,

On my trip up the M42 / A42 (UK) at the weekend - my 2610 wanted me to get off, go round the roundabout, and re-join on EVERY junction on the way up, and EVERY junction on the way back. I can't believe this fits in with your explanation above - surely this must be a Garmin software bug?

My SPIII has done that in the past when going up the A12.....

I think I'd been tweaking settings or maybe it was after a bike trip when I'd set it to keep me off motorways but then told it to find the fastest route when back in the car.....I decided she was seeing the long slip roads up to roundabouts as direct roads to the destination that weren't motorways, so she routed me up them...if that makes sense :confused:
 
Roland Butter said:
Pan,

On my trip up the M42 / A42 (UK) at the weekend - my 2610 wanted me to get off, go round the roundabout, and re-join on EVERY junction on the way up, and EVERY junction on the way back. I can't believe this fits in with your explanation above - surely this must be a Garmin software bug?

I saw this on my SPIII when I had Avoid Highways checked in the routing preferences. Once that box was unchecked, the problem vanished.

Greg
 
Happens in the USA as well - uncheck the 'Avoid Highways' box...

Mike:)

ps If they just highlighted the slip roads as 'part of a highway/motorway', surely this would cure this daft problem:confused:
 
Greg Masters said:
I saw this on my SPIII when I had Avoid Highways checked in the routing preferences. Once that box was unchecked, the problem vanished.

Greg

I always have the "avoid highways" checked. I prefer the back roads. That's what GSes are for. Come on get off that motorway.
 
Howard Millichap said:
I always have the "avoid highways" checked. I prefer the back roads. That's what GSes are for. Come on get off that motorway.

So did I, but Betty still took me on to the motorway when I asked her for the fastest route. Then she had a bit of a giggle with me sending me off and back on at every junction. Thanks to the friendly advice from everyone, I'm now a bit wiser.

Still confused about Garmins' definition of 'avoid' though. It clearly doesn't mean avoid completely, presume it means something along the lines of 'avoid unless it reduces journey time by > n%'. Anyone got a more accurate explanation?

Still, now with 3.40, should be able to customise to personal preferences anywho :)
 


Back
Top Bottom