Agreed.
So called 'winter' gloves leak, let draughts in and leech dye- plus they make your fingers feel like balloons and remove you from the feeling on being in control of the bike- they're a struggle to get on, you always remember that you haven't done up your helmet straps, undone the disc lock or whatever, then you have all that bloody hassle again
Not only that, but a decent winter glove will set you back a tonne, so most of us will only lash out on one pair- you'll get them wet and there's nothing worse than pulling on a pair of wet gloves....they sap your will to ride and make the whole day poo.
Winter gloves are pants- they either don't work, or they're so much hassle they're not worth it....Muffs may look odd (but WGAF?) but they work, period.
Summer gloves, heated grips and muffs, job done.