I like mine a lot.
I also still have my 2011 GSA. Here’s the main differences:
First off, they are not really comparable. Although both large capacity adventure style bikes they are in reality chalk and cheese. Nevertheless....
V85 is light and narrow so easy to handle at very low speed or push about.
You have a feeling of sitting on the V85 rather than in on the GSA.
I miss the extra grunt of the GSA. Real world speed is not really compromised but overtaking definitely needs more planning. And an impromptu wheelie off a crest just doesn’t happen on the V85. (Oh ok, not really a wheelie but a decent lift of the front wheel in 3rd or 4th). The lack of grunt especially noticeable when two-up (obvs but worth a mention).
Standard screen is very airy and noisy. To the extent that I really do need to do something about it. Airy is good when it’s warm as I do find the GSA very hot to ride when it’s very warm. Conversely the V85 is a very cold bike to ride in winter - heated jacket almost on max on the V85 compared to no more than half on the GSA.
The GSA definitely handles a lot better than the V85. My gsa does have Wilbers & ESA so is particularly good in that regard but the standard V85 rear shock is manual preload and rebound adjustable only. It is easily overwhelmed when two-up plus a bit of luggage with pegs, stands and even pillion’s heels dragging far too easily and dangerously so if a corner has a suspension chomping dip on the apex. There’s a few alternative shocks and front springs out there mainly from the Italian manufacturers.
The V85 will sound a lot lot better with a slightly more open exhaust system. It’s on my shopping list. My GSA with standard can but no flappy valve sounds just about right imho.
So far I haven’t found many solutions to over-packing the bike for a two-up camping trip. I have the standard aluminium luggage which is fine for a solo trip or a non camping two up trip. All the bike specific tank bags I have seen are rather small, I have yet to see anything like crash bar bags or other ways of getting some storage up front. No little pannier frame mounted tool boxes and the like available (yet).
Build quality on the V85 looks to really good. Better than the BMW and especially better than the newer ones. Switchgear on the V85 is a bit odd though and lacks feedback in use.
Which do I prefer? I like/dislike each bike for different reasons so it’s not a case which one I prefer it’s a case of the right tool for the job and how much you are prepared to compromise when the V85 isn’t quite right but is sooo much better in other areas.
I think that's a pretty fair assessment Austin and would totally agree. I don't use mine two up, I've something else for that. I've used mine for several solo camping trips and apart from the odd occasion when a bit more grunt would have been nice I've thoroughly enjoyed it. As for the suspension I used the settings that someone else had spent some time setting up and it's greatly improved the handling, although it wasn't bad to start with. Front...back it right off to soft and 3 clicks toward hard. Rear....Damping (preload) I run on the 3rd notch of the spring compressor. Rebound....back it right off to soft and a 1/2 turn to hard. Not normally settings I would have tried but it works. (solo)
Another thing you may wish to try. On the modes, the bike seems to be much more responsive in 'Off Road' mode. Some folk are saying they think that the modes may have been mixed up when installed. Yes, you lose rear ABS in off road, but unless it's chucking it down it doesn't really bother me.