450 GS - first impressions

Flaneur

New member
UKGSer Subscriber
Joined
Feb 14, 2012
Messages
4
Reaction score
33
Location
Derry, NI
It is intriguing that virtually all the reviews of the 450 GS have been of the Trophy or the Sport versions. I have seen nothing about the Exclusive. On hearing about the imminent emergence of the 450 GS I was both excited and intrigued. I have owned many GS models, from basic to adventure, but have, since 2014, been riding an RNineT which for me is the closest I can get to the perfect motorcycle. The dimensions are perfect (I am 5'11"), it is the ideal capacity and the engine delivers the power in a manner which complements the roads I ride around north west Ireland. Despite the perfection of the R9T, however, I still yearned for a GS. I bought a 310 GS and quite liked it but became bored with it after a year or so passing it on to a friend who I think has yet to ride it!

At my age (over 70) I knew the larger GS machines were probably a non-starter, mainly in terms of getting them in and out of the garage not necessarily on the road so the 450 GS seemed the perfect solution. I placed an order for a Trophy and then when I went to see it in the showroom began to have doubts. I was almost sure the ERC clutch would both irritate and confuse me after so many years using a proper clutch and the colour scheme began to irritate also, particularly the white frame. My friend who was with me did not help this thought by proclaiming that the Trophy looked like Mickey Marley's roundabout, a gaudy children's ride which toured the streets of Belfast in the 1940s and 50s. The black Exclusive was skulking in the back of the showroom and the more I looked at it the more I desired it. For clarity I generally gravitate to black in most things and will continue to do so until someone designs a darker colour. The other draw was that I could have the Exclusive immediately rather than having to wait until September for the Trophy by which time in truth I might well be dead.

So the Exclusive was collected last week and I have put about 300 miles on it. The first hour I thought I had made a real mistake but I then realised I was trying to ride it as I would the R9T. Old habits and all that. Once I realised that it needed to be 'hooliganed' a little it began to make sense. Firstly, let us be clear this is not just a bigger 310 Gs. This is a proper thing. It is quite high and while I can get my feet flat on the ground it is still imposing enough to make one concentrate. It pulls well in every gear (although I am still running it in) and handles exactly as one would expect a GS to. It does not feel underpowered and pulls well out of corners and when overtaking. The quick shift gearbox is a joy and I am certain I made the correct choice not going ERC as I am too old to start riding a scooter again. The riding position is again as one would expect a GS to be and the seat is genuinely comfortable, a little hard but not tiring on longer runs. (I did about three hours in one session.)

Most critically I think the black looks quite special. Not flash, not anonymous but just going about its business with an aura of sophistication which I think both the Trophy and the Sport lack. But then they are aimed at younger riders who have not yet learned the importance of black to anyone who wishes to appear even mildly cool.

So to this point all good, although it is only 300 miles. I will offer a more detailed account as the miles progress.
 
Having recently had the urge for some retail therapy I had a big fuck it moment and put a deposit on the Trophy version because I love the colour scheme which is the same as my 1250. The purchase is subject to me liking it when I'm able to test ride one.

I was interested and pleased to hear your positive thoughts so please keep them coming.

Many on the launch seemed to like the auto clutch so I hope I do to.

The demo model at Cotswold BMW Cheltenham was crashed sadly so hopefully they will have a replacement very soon

Mine may come in June but they can't confirm yet.

WhatsApp Image 2026-06-12 at 2.06.28 PM.jpeg
 
It is intriguing that virtually all the reviews of the 450 GS have been of the Trophy or the Sport versions. I have seen nothing about the Exclusive. On hearing about the imminent emergence of the 450 GS I was both excited and intrigued. I have owned many GS models, from basic to adventure, but have, since 2014, been riding an RNineT which for me is the closest I can get to the perfect motorcycle. The dimensions are perfect (I am 5'11"), it is the ideal capacity and the engine delivers the power in a manner which complements the roads I ride around north west Ireland. Despite the perfection of the R9T, however, I still yearned for a GS. I bought a 310 GS and quite liked it but became bored with it after a year or so passing it on to a friend who I think has yet to ride it!

At my age (over 70) I knew the larger GS machines were probably a non-starter, mainly in terms of getting them in and out of the garage not necessarily on the road so the 450 GS seemed the perfect solution. I placed an order for a Trophy and then when I went to see it in the showroom began to have doubts. I was almost sure the ERC clutch would both irritate and confuse me after so many years using a proper clutch and the colour scheme began to irritate also, particularly the white frame. My friend who was with me did not help this thought by proclaiming that the Trophy looked like Mickey Marley's roundabout, a gaudy children's ride which toured the streets of Belfast in the 1940s and 50s. The black Exclusive was skulking in the back of the showroom and the more I looked at it the more I desired it. For clarity I generally gravitate to black in most things and will continue to do so until someone designs a darker colour. The other draw was that I could have the Exclusive immediately rather than having to wait until September for the Trophy by which time in truth I might well be dead.

So the Exclusive was collected last week and I have put about 300 miles on it. The first hour I thought I had made a real mistake but I then realised I was trying to ride it as I would the R9T. Old habits and all that. Once I realised that it needed to be 'hooliganed' a little it began to make sense. Firstly, let us be clear this is not just a bigger 310 Gs. This is a proper thing. It is quite high and while I can get my feet flat on the ground it is still imposing enough to make one concentrate. It pulls well in every gear (although I am still running it in) and handles exactly as one would expect a GS to. It does not feel underpowered and pulls well out of corners and when overtaking. The quick shift gearbox is a joy and I am certain I made the correct choice not going ERC as I am too old to start riding a scooter again. The riding position is again as one would expect a GS to be and the seat is genuinely comfortable, a little hard but not tiring on longer runs. (I did about three hours in one session.)

Most critically I think the black looks quite special. Not flash, not anonymous but just going about its business with an aura of sophistication which I think both the Trophy and the Sport lack. But then they are aimed at younger riders who have not yet learned the importance of black to anyone who wishes to appear even mildly cool.

So to this point all good, although it is only 300 miles. I will offer a more detailed account as the miles progress.
Let’s have a pic you new bike then 😊
 
@Flaneur , I too have an R9t Scrambler and want a 450 GS to add onto my Land Cruiser for town and trail hopping in Spain and the like. However, I won’t be buying it with the ERC.
I see a few Indian YouTube channels are saying avoid the ERC as it’s a costly repair and prone to wear, so I think you have chosen correctly. Best model they advocate is non ERC and with sports suspension.
Until the 450 GS is offered with spoked wheels and no ERC then I will not be buying. The Aprillia Tuareg 457 due to be launched at Eicma this November is higher on my list.
Enjoy your new ride and do report back.
 
For clarity I generally gravitate to black in most things and will continue to do so until someone designs a darker colour.

Thanks for penning your thoughts Flaneur, is the RNineT gone or have you kept it as your benchmark that the 450 has to rise to?

New one to me so was worth reading for that line alone 😆 👍
 
Having recently had the urge for some retail therapy I had a big fuck it moment and put a deposit on the Trophy version because I love the colour scheme......

Mine may come in June but they can't confirm yet.

View attachment 512516
Blimey, you must be the youngest GSer there is...you look totally different to how I'd imagined you......(Enjoy your purchase!)
 
Thanks for penning your thoughts Flaneur, is the RNineT gone or have you kept it as your benchmark that the 450 has to rise to?

New one to me so was worth reading for that line alone 😆 👍
The R9T is here for the long haul. I have never ridden a machine which offers me the ability to feel confident in both its capabilities and mine. So the F450 GS and the R9T will garage together as strange bedfellows. If it is relevant I also have a collection of Velocette machines as well, one of which was sat upon by Prince William on a visit to Belfast. More importantly the pride of this bunch is a 1930 KTT which was reputedly raced in the 1930s by Tim Hunt.
 
Blimey, you must be the youngest GSer there is...you look totally different to how I'd imagined you......(Enjoy your purchase!)

Ha, ha, I wish! This is Henry, my youngest and living the dream.

He'd love to join us on our trips but would want to go faster faster faster all the time.
 
Third decent ride of the running in period today. Weather glorious and an interesting route through Fermanagh where even the B roads tend to have grass up the middle. The running in business is frustrating because the machine does want to go. It hits the running in rev limit remarkably rapidly in every gear and this, I think, bodes well for future travels. I have also been using the quick shift gear change and have to say it is, to this point, flawless with each and every gear dropping in smoothly - up or down the box - and without any impact on engine speed. The last part of the journey was, even at limited revs, exhilarating, coming up over a small mountain road which had actual grass growing up the middle and at each side. The machine fully made sense for the first time sitting at 55/60 miles per hour and gliding through bends and over any road obstacle thrown up. It is not tiring to ride even for a rider of my maturity and is light, agile and quietly inspiring.

I watched an interesting review on YT last night of the Trophy and the reviewer was deeply frustrated by the ERC clutch especially its tendency to do nothing until about 2500 revs which convinced me even more that I had made the right decision and opted for the Exclusive. Some commentators have complained of vibration but I have not had the luxury of the kinds of revs, or speeds, which might bring that vibration on so will be interested in finding out if that is indeed a thing. Conversely the same commentators suggested that this vibration was mainly on motorways and larger dual carriageway type routes. Ah...that is not, categorically, what this machine is for.

More tomorrow if the weather holds.
 
I took one out today (a video will follow)
Briefly

LIkes
Punchy revvy engine a real joy to use
Great handling really flickable but also stable and confidence inspiring
It felt light
Comfy (apart from the seat)
The I am on a mini GS feel
Brakes
front end
Good wind protection at 80

Dislikes
Seat so hard it feels like obsidian
Choppy rear shock
The stupid e clutch - it worked ok and Its intuitive but why would you want one ???
For me it felt a bit physically small

Overall really nice I would go for the one without the eclutch

It doesn't have the character of a Himi 450 but it has a fair bit more shove

Really enjoyed it TBH

As I said I am videoing thse type of bikes
i have done the KLE
Have the Himi waiting on editing
This in pre edit
We are doing the triumph next
 


Back
Top Bottom