Bennetts via comparison site - beware

wessie

Well-known member
UKGSer Subscriber
Joined
Jan 8, 2002
Messages
19,624
Reaction score
7,720
Location
Welshpool
I have had to cancel a policy taken out via Bennetts. I did this before the policy started and received a full refund. I made a formal complaint which was handled well.

Circumstances: current policy with Ageas via Devitt expires on 2nd June. The renewal price of £126 was favourable but I noted they still had me as employed. I rang to get a new quote as now retired. This raised the price by over £40 and made it too dear.

Off I toddled to the comparison sites and Bennetts offered a good price via an Aviva policy through MCN Compare. I bought the policy. Fortunately I checked the documents when they were emailed through. I noticed there was a difference in the Statement of Fact section compared to the information typed into the MCN Compare website. This relates to a medical condition I have to declare to DVLA. The usual format of the question is "Do you have a medical condition that you have reported to DVLA" YES. This generates a drop down from which I select "DVLA Aware, no restrictions" as I use a CPAP machine. Annoyingly, the questions on Bennetts form are worded differently.

I then had a long phone call with Bennetts. The chappie on the phone was hopeless and he didn't get any better after consulting his supervisor. I was not at all confident I trusted my contract for insurance. I then looked at the online customer portal and noted there was an option to cancel the policy but reading the small print, they stated they would charge me a £10 fee plus would not return the £20 brokerage fee already paid. That's a large chunk from a £143 premium bearing in mind the policy was not yet live.

I then emailed a formal complaint stating the above and telling them they could fuck off in relation to the cancellation fees.

To their credit, I had an email after cancelling the policy online stating the full £143 would be repaid and a phone call today asking if I was happy to close the complaint. She was very apologetic and has fed back to the overlords about the problems I encountered. This evening, the refund has hit my credit card account.

The main message here is do not assume the information you enter onto a comparison site carries forward correctly to the broker's website. Check the data before you go through to the payment section and the documents once you get them.

There was a happy ending as well. The chappie working for Devitt was much keener. He rang back a day or two later and stated he had persuaded the renewals team to review the price offered and I was offered a revised premium of £123. I'll put that £40 towards dinner in Reims on Friday evening.
 
I had similar - my statement of facts had an omission, so i queried it , they had one less security option noted ( turns out i missed it last year too)

lol even when added it made no difference to the premium yeah right, i can guarantee it would have done had i have to make a claim ;)

All my medical conditions dont have to be declared which is good

Dont get me started on there charges, they make shylock look like a saint :D
 
Amazingly being retired will raise the insurance.
I queried this and was told, I might not be using the vehicle everyday for work, but now I’m retired I will use the vehicle more.
As soon as I got a part time job, which involves commuting, I phoned them and my premium dropped.
 
Amazingly being retired will raise the insurance.
I queried this and was told, I might not be using the vehicle everyday for work, but now I’m retired I will use the vehicle more.
As soon as I got a part time job, which involves commuting, I phoned them and my premium dropped.


So how does that work if you stay within the declared mileage ?
 
So how does that work if you stay within the declared mileage ?
Exactly. I even tried explaining that I would be using it less but the monkey on the other end just has a drop down menu in front of them and they go by that.
 
You would think that commuting would increase risk and hence the premium.

The bike was not insured for commuting when I was employed as after COVID I was mostly working at home. Occasional business trips were by car.
 
I had a similar experience with info not being transferred from the comparison site to the insurer. In my case it was bike modifications.
The premium was £245. The modifications, once added properly by the insurer, added another £245 onto the premium. That was too much so I cancelled it and went onto the insurers website and got the same cover for £255. Go figure.
 
If buying from a price comparison site I leave time between purchase and inception to allow for correcting any errors in the transfer of imformation to the insurer or for cancellation if that increases the premium.
Also, if given the option, elect to have documents emailed rather than by post so you can check them before the policy begins. Finding errors after cover starts means cancellation and short term cover charges, proving who made the error would be a long, drawn out process with hair (or remains of it) loss likely, either through stress or pulling it out.
 


Back
Top Bottom