BMW Insurance blues + driving test dates.

er-minio

Well-known member
UKGSer Subscriber
Joined
Mar 10, 2008
Messages
10,432
Reaction score
3,443
Location
London/Rome
My insurance is up for renewal mid May.

I'm having a few issues lately, I'm getting properly annoyed at this stage and I might be happy to be pointed towards other insurers and to get some advice.

Background:
Been in the UK since 2007. Got my first UK bike (R1100S Boxercup) in 2009ish, insured through Bennetts, then moved to BMW Financial Services. Been insured with them ever since.

I started with a clean slate, since it was a pain to translate all the docs from my italian insurance. My first premium was 1200, then went down around 500/600 quid per year, staying roughly the same even after Sept 2013 when I bought a 1200 GSA and added it to the policy (the extra bike was 100ish more a year).

Got my bike license in Italy in 1997. Converted to UK (late, my bad) in 2013.

I sold the Boxercup and bought an HP2 Sport last year.
So: 2007 GSA and 2011 HP2S.
Insurance went up to 1700 and was also forced to have a comprehensive cover. :eek:
Paid that ok. Everyone happy (not really).

I spoke with the insurer on the phone a few times. They explained me that since the bikes are garaged in what they consider a "public" garage, the insurance price is high. For the insurance it's like if I leave them on the street, at least this is what they told me.
If I managed to put the bikes in a lock-up where I was the only one with access, the price could have gone down to around 1k.

I live near central London. Prices for a lock-up are insane. The ones I tried to rent looked like bloody fucking cardboard boxes (for 200 quid a month minimum) with paper thin doors.
I've been using the garage where the bikes are for AGES. It is guarded. CCTV. It is closed at night. No access whatsoever. I'm happy with that.
The bike is chained + disc lock.

Now, a few weeks ago, I had a collision with the GS. Info here: http://www.ukgser.com/forums/showthread.php/396634-Collision-involving-pedestrian

Communicated that to the insurance. All ok.
They told me, since I wasn't at fault, it would have not affected my premium. Yeah right.

Now I get my policy renewal letter. 1799.
6 years NCB (up from 5 last year).

I call them to ask why the price wasn't any lower (it alway went down a bit the previous years), then I wanted to correct the statement of insurance because:

a) the accident I reported wasn't written up anywhere
b) regardless of the 6 years NCB it says that I have 2 years experience driving in the UK and that my driving test was passed on March 2013.

They told me the driving test dates and experience don't change anything. I begged to disagree, since we are talking about 10+ years of experience.
I also made them noticed that I've been insured through them for the last 5 years... so they should have double checked the dates, also because they have on file either my old Italian license and the UK one that replaced it.

They rang up the insurer (ERS) and, adding the collision (no claims on both sides, I wasn't at fault - I didn't claim my own damages, just ate it up) my premium goes up to 2060 quid, including the 10 quid fee for the pleasure to renew with them.


Now.
I'm not really up to renew on these terms.
The problem is even worse. Every other insurer I rang up refuses to insure me, as they don't like the HP2 to be insured at the address I give them. Not even at my home address.
I had similar problems when I had the Boxercup, but apparently only with Carol Nash, Bennets was ok, as was BMW Financial.

I'm technically unable to get a fucking quote from another insurer, and I'm being "held by the balls" by my current insurer. :D

So. Yes. It is an expensive bike. But we are talking a newish GSA worth (insured value is 10k, that is BELOW market value).
So, I have friends who insure Porsche cars that are worth 4 times that and parked on the street day and night, at similar premium fees, and no one bats an eye.


In all of this, I also have a car happily insured with Admiral. 4 years NCB (my first car here). No fuss.
All of this is not take in account (2 bikes + 1 car - no convictions whatsoever, I add up a decent amount of mileage per year combining car and GS, etc. etc.) anyway I digress...

What shall I do about the driving test dates.
Every time I speak with another insurer they use my ITA to UK conversion date as the start date for my license. Does it affect the policy? I guess so.

I can try to move the bikes at a different address in a relatively short time.
But I'm basically at the Insurer's mercy.

Do I need to ring the insurer and give them a range of places where to keep the bikes and see where they are happy with it? WTF...
Is there any way to fight back the increase in the policy after the collision, or is it just wasted time?

I'm not looking to spend 50 quid a year on the policy.
I knew it would have been expensive when I got the HP. it's just that at the moment I'm stuck with a single insurer and they can do whatever they want since I'm not able to quote/move anywhere else.

Carol Nash won't insure.
The one through UKGSer (forgot the name), they've been lovely, but they won't insure.
Hastings won't insure.

I's a bike, not a motherfucking Picasso left by the bins next to a pub. :D

Cheers.
 
So, been phoning up insurances all day.
I have some follow up that I'd like to have clarified, if possible.

I quoted two separate policies for the GS and the HP2 with Carole Nash. The grand total for the two policies is lower than what BMW/ERS quoted.
Tomorrow I'll try to combine it into a multipolicy and see if it changes anything.

Questions are:

- for the insurance system, my motorbike license starts with the UK license conversion.
So instead of 18 years of license, I have two. And I'm riding a bike with 130 odd bhp (and a power ratio close to 1bhp per kilo) and another one with 100something bhp.
Trying to understand if that is a problem in the premium calculation. And why this is happening.
I understand there is a few differences (more than a few) from the italian bike test and the, better, UK one. But I just did a conversion. Handed over one license, got the other one in the post. I did no additional tests.
Shall I do advance riding courses? Does it help?

- doing a separate policy, I asked for the HP2 to be third party only. Every insurer refuses to insure for third party only or third party and fire and theft. They only cover if I get a comprehensive cover. How is that legal? Last time I checked you only need third party to drive on the public road. If I damage the bike myself, I've been a knob, I'll pay out of my own pocket (I never used comprehensive till I was forced to do so last year). If I don't want any refund if the bike gets stolen, well, that is my own risk.
Again, I undestand an insurance company can refuse, but there should be an option to just get what is required by law and not the full package that, I insist, I won't even use.

- regarding the BMW quote, how the fuck a collision with no claims and no fault can affect my premium? I understand that the other party has three years to change its mind, but... charge me if and when a claim is made, or litigation is on.
Next time I'm in a collision, I won't be a decend individual and I won't call the police myself but I'll just keep it hush hush then. This seems like the message being passed on.
 
Shall I do advance riding courses? Does it help?
With some insurers but not all.

- doing a separate policy, I asked for the HP2 to be third party only. Every insurer refuses to insure for third party only or third party and fire and theft. They only cover if I get a comprehensive cover. How is that legal?
It's legal because the law doesn't oblige them to offer a 3rd party only policy.

regarding the BMW quote, how the fuck a collision with no claims and no fault can affect my premium?
That insurer chooses to consider you a higher risk customer because of the accident. Others may not.
 
It's legal because the law doesn't oblige them to offer a 3rd party only policy.

But isn't third party the only type of insurance required by law to be on the public road?
If I decide to take the risk not to get any money back if a bike is stolen, that could/should be my choice.
Just out of curiosity.

That insurer chooses to consider you a higher risk customer because of the accident. Others may not.

Ok. Makes sense.

By the way, I forgot to mention that the bike is gray import (I bought it abroad) if that makes any difference.
 
My insurance is up for renewal mid May.

I'm having a few issues lately, I'm getting properly annoyed at this stage and I might be happy to be pointed towards other insurers and to get some advice.

Background:
Been in the UK since 2007. Got my first UK bike (R1100S Boxercup) in 2009ish, insured through Bennetts, then moved to BMW Financial Services. Been insured with them ever since.

I started with a clean slate, since it was a pain to translate all the docs from my italian insurance. My first premium was 1200, then went down around 500/600 quid per year, staying roughly the same even after Sept 2013 when I bought a 1200 GSA and added it to the policy (the extra bike was 100ish more a year).

Got my bike license in Italy in 1997. Converted to UK (late, my bad) in 2013.

I sold the Boxercup and bought an HP2 Sport last year.
So: 2007 GSA and 2011 HP2S.
Insurance went up to 1700 and was also forced to have a comprehensive cover. :eek:
Paid that ok. Everyone happy (not really).

I spoke with the insurer on the phone a few times. They explained me that since the bikes are garaged in what they consider a "public" garage, the insurance price is high. For the insurance it's like if I leave them on the street, at least this is what they told me.
If I managed to put the bikes in a lock-up where I was the only one with access, the price could have gone down to around 1k.

I live near central London. Prices for a lock-up are insane. The ones I tried to rent looked like bloody fucking cardboard boxes (for 200 quid a month minimum) with paper thin doors.
I've been using the garage where the bikes are for AGES. It is guarded. CCTV. It is closed at night. No access whatsoever. I'm happy with that.
The bike is chained + disc lock.

Now, a few weeks ago, I had a collision with the GS. Info here: http://www.ukgser.com/forums/showthread.php/396634-Collision-involving-pedestrian

Communicated that to the insurance. All ok.
They told me, since I wasn't at fault, it would have not affected my premium. Yeah right.

Now I get my policy renewal letter. 1799.
6 years NCB (up from 5 last year).

I call them to ask why the price wasn't any lower (it alway went down a bit the previous years), then I wanted to correct the statement of insurance because:

a) the accident I reported wasn't written up anywhere
b) regardless of the 6 years NCB it says that I have 2 years experience driving in the UK and that my driving test was passed on March 2013.

They told me the driving test dates and experience don't change anything. I begged to disagree, since we are talking about 10+ years of experience.
I also made them noticed that I've been insured through them for the last 5 years... so they should have double checked the dates, also because they have on file either my old Italian license and the UK one that replaced it.

They rang up the insurer (ERS) and, adding the collision (no claims on both sides, I wasn't at fault - I didn't claim my own damages, just ate it up) my premium goes up to 2060 quid, including the 10 quid fee for the pleasure to renew with them.


Now.
I'm not really up to renew on these terms.
The problem is even worse. Every other insurer I rang up refuses to insure me, as they don't like the HP2 to be insured at the address I give them. Not even at my home address.
I had similar problems when I had the Boxercup, but apparently only with Carol Nash, Bennets was ok, as was BMW Financial.

I'm technically unable to get a fucking quote from another insurer, and I'm being "held by the balls" by my current insurer. :D

So. Yes. It is an expensive bike. But we are talking a newish GSA worth (insured value is 10k, that is BELOW market value).
So, I have friends who insure Porsche cars that are worth 4 times that and parked on the street day and night, at similar premium fees, and no one bats an eye.


In all of this, I also have a car happily insured with Admiral. 4 years NCB (my first car here). No fuss.
All of this is not take in account (2 bikes + 1 car - no convictions whatsoever, I add up a decent amount of mileage per year combining car and GS, etc. etc.) anyway I digress...

What shall I do about the driving test dates.
Every time I speak with another insurer they use my ITA to UK conversion date as the start date for my license. Does it affect the policy? I guess so.

I can try to move the bikes at a different address in a relatively short time.
But I'm basically at the Insurer's mercy.

Do I need to ring the insurer and give them a range of places where to keep the bikes and see where they are happy with it? WTF...
Is there any way to fight back the increase in the policy after the collision, or is it just wasted time?

I'm not looking to spend 50 quid a year on the policy.
I knew it would have been expensive when I got the HP. it's just that at the moment I'm stuck with a single insurer and they can do whatever they want since I'm not able to quote/move anywhere else.

Carol Nash won't insure.
The one through UKGSer (forgot the name), they've been lovely, but they won't insure.
Hastings won't insure.

I's a bike, not a motherfucking Picasso left by the bins next to a pub. :D

Cheers.

You have the answer to your problem in the text.
Every insurer regards you as high risk
Hence the high premium.
If they are all doing it then it is basic math in the calculation not someone trying to screw you.

One of the problems of living in London
 
I was in a similar situation 6 years ago. I had a Belgian license and moved to the UK but did not transfer the license. Also imported a 1yr old GSA with me. Kept on the street in London.

Insurance was with BMW paid about 600. They were happy to accept an EU license and the statement of insurance clearly stated I had an EU license. Now I have a K1300S and am also paying 600, but I passed my test in 2009 in Belgium

What seems to be affecting your situation, I think, is that when you changed to a UK license they started using that as the start date and now you've got an HP2 with only 2 years of experience! In general there was no need for you to switch your license. You can use an EU one until you're 70.

Of course the accident is also affecting the premium

Only suggestion I have is to call a broker.
 
comprehensive insurance is usually not much more than TPF&T these days IME. in fact, i've heard of some companies quoting more for TPF&T than comp!
 
What seems to be affecting your situation, I think, is that when you changed to a UK license they started using that as the start date and now you've got an HP2 with only 2 years of experience! In general there was no need for you to switch your license. You can use an EU one until you're 70.

I am a UK resident. I've been since 2007.
I've been insured on British plated vehicles since early 2009.
You are required to switch your license within 3 years.

update: "You can drive in Great Britain on a full, valid driving licence from another EU country until you’re 70, or for 3 years after becoming resident in Great Britain, whichever is longer."
You are right.

I'll convert back to Italian license then.
Good luck with the points. :D

No one informed me of this change of date crap. Because crap it is.

My UK plastic driving license still states 1997 at the back, where my A license test date is.

Before I switched the IT/UK license, my insurance premium went up a bit and the insurer told me on the phone (MBW/Devitts) that it was because I still had my italian license after 3+ years being a resident in the UK and, I quote, "it looks dodgy for the system because you are supposed to convert the license and you are not".

So, this is one thing.

Second thing, and this is because I'm told that the insurance is not trying to screw me: 3 insurers on the phone admitted that 40% of my premium was due to where the bike was kept at night, hence the high premium.
So, I decide to take the risk on me and not insure it for fire and theft, and then I'm not allowed to do that, even though fire and theft and comprehensive covers are not required by law to use a motor vehicle on the public road? Bullshit.

comprehensive insurance is usually not much more than TPF&T these days IME. in fact, i've heard of some companies quoting more for TPF&T than comp!

Yeah, it might be even cheaper in some cases.

Anwyay, I'm probably getting an acceptable cover with another insurer (fully comp) and I'll probably go with that, but I'm still unhappy about the 2 years experience I have on the insurance system now, and I don't like being forced into buying services I don't need by insurance companies.
They are refusing to quote for just third party.

I'm going to have a chat with the financial ombudsman services.
 
Since you're willing to take only 3rd party and since they're not willing to quote that, couldn't you just get a fully comp quote and tell them that the bike is garaged in a lock up (maybe a friend has one whose address you can use - maybe in an area of London where there are fewer bike thefts?). You don't bother to put it in the lock up and if it does get stolen from the garage you do use, it's on you, which it would be anyway if you had only 3rd party. They wont care since you've not claimed on the policy for theft anyway

Or would this be fraud? ;)

My paperwork says that the bike is not covered for theft if it is stolen from an area less than 500m from where I have stated that it's garaged.
 
Or would this be fraud?

It would.
My point being, why shall I commit insurance fraud ("fraud" being a big word here, to be clear) because I'm being forced in buying a product that I don't want. It's not much more a money thing, as I'll probably end up with another fully comp policy, but it's just me being livid about all of this. I cannot believe they are allowed to do this.
 
Insurance companies do not have to offer you insurance. It is up to them to decide what type of policy to offer and at what cost depending on how they value your risk. Just because insurance is required does not mean it has to be offered. It would be far better if third party insurance was covered in road tax like in some other countries but it isn't so no point discussing it. I had a simillar problem when I lived in London as my bike was in the front garden under the window a lot of companies refused to insure me. Mind you when I moved to Rochdale and put it in a brick garage my premium doubled. One company even offered to cover me for anywhere in the world (Including Iraq, Afganistan, Lybia - I asked out of curiosity) but when I gave them an OL postcode for Rochdale they refused me cover ! The problem is you need insurance, they know it, you are screwed every time. I now have 2 bikes on seperate policies as trying to get cover for a GS and a Husky on one policy was impossible.

Also, apparently as I told them the bike is in a garage if it is stolen off my drive I am not covered for theft. Asked what would happen if I went in the house to get the garage keys and the bike was stolen and they replied I would not be covered - go figure.

All you can do is keep on trying and hopefully get to talk to somebody with a bit of a brain who can ring the insurance company and do a deal for you.
 
All you can do is keep on trying and hopefully get to talk to somebody with a bit of a brain who can ring the insurance company and do a deal for you.

Credit where due:

I spoke twice with this woman at BMW Financial Services and she was very helpful (there was also a massive cock-up in the statement). Still they confirmed the price.
Carol Nash: I spoke with a couple of guys that at least think before talking. We got to the point where the underwriter (Aviva) asked my motorbiking history and had them check that I've been previously insured on 1000+cc bikes in the UK.
I got a quote for exaclty 50% what BMW is asking (same excess), the only issue is that I'm not covered at all for theft if the bike is not kept in the garage. So I'm contemplating this or just look away and pay BMW with the other hand... :D
The issue is, while one bike is always garaged, I use the GS like a car and almost everyday and for everything, and sometimes it stays overnight at another location that is not a garage. But anyway... I had this problem before with the Boxercup.

Two different insurance contracts for the two bikes is out of the question, because the GS will start a new policy on 0 years NCB and they gave me a quick quote that was in the area of 3k annually (bike value is around 6 I think). :D
 
I would suggest it would be wise to have theft cover..
I understand your dilemma as I have a friend who is Hungarian & they crucify her for a cheap ish Peugeot 206..
 
Silly idea (probably) but try asking for a quote with a 'partner' included.

My car insurance went down SIGNIFICANTLY when I included Rosie on it......even though she's on a provisional license :nenau

I suspect the insurance formulas are a bit odd......fuzzy logic that says if a vehicle is for family use, it's more likely to be looked after.

No idea if it will make an ounce of difference in your case, but it's worth a try :thumb2
 
Silly idea (probably) but try asking for a quote with a 'partner' included.

Hey fanum, thanks! My girlfriend lives in Italy at the moment. She doesn't hold an A license. But good to know. I might try that, when possible, on the car insurance.

I suspect the insurance formulas are a bit odd...

To say the least.
I might have found a solution. Moving the bikes to two separate policies as said before. So I can insure one as garaged (it is always) and the GS that I use everyday can be insured at another location + commuting + pillion cover, etc. etc.
The combined premiums so far are 600 quid cheaper than BMW/ERS' quote. :D

The interesting bit, I will keep my existing policy and 6 years NCB on the HP, and start the GS on a brand new policy with 0 years NCB.
Of course, NCB is tied to the policy. Fair enough.
The accidents are not. They have to be declared on both. Even the guy on the phone said "doesn't sound fair, doesn't it" :D

Then: the company that accepts to insure the HP gives me a decent premium, but quoted me 2800gbp for a new policy (third party and fire and theft) for the GS since the 0 years NCB.
Another insurer, that I'll use to insure the GS on its own, quoted me on exactly the same terms 460gbp.

I understand every insurer calculates risk in different ways... but the price gap is massive :D :D :D
 
Spoke too soon.
No insurance offered anymore, as they assumed it was a lock-up, despite me giving them the all the details of the parking last time, including company reg, address, website and all. Again, third party only is not an option.

Had to go through ERS and shell 2k over the fucking phone. Hope all the paperwork comes with correct information over the next few days.
I will have to change my parking solutions in the next few months for other reasons and I'm also installing a ground anchor at home anyway, so that might affect (I hope for the better) the policy.
A couple of years ago I did some variations and got a refund on the policy.
 


Back
Top Bottom