Hot Starting Issues — 1250 GSA

Globetrotter

Registered user
Joined
May 25, 2025
Messages
109
Reaction score
64
Location
NW, England
Hi guys 🖐 first post

Had to abandon a two week trip by ten days last week!

Hot starting issues on the 2019 which seems to be a common issue with this years model?

I've had the bike since November and changed the battery (like for like) a couple of weeks after buying it and has been fine through the winter and a 1000 mile ride through Scotland only a few weeks ago with no issues whatsoever — someone recommended the Motobatt Hybrid MHTX16 CCA350 which is perfect for this hot starting issue and with a better lifespan than the Motobatt MBYZ16H CCA240 but there's been none in the UK for weeks now so waiting on a delivery from Italy, shame really, as I wasn't a million miles away from Italy at the time when it all started.

Point of the thread is if anyone is aware whether a Valve Clearance Adjustment would be beneficial for this issue please? As I feel like I need to double up on sorting the issue.

Cheers
 
As you have probably already realised this hot starting `characteristic` is well-known and there are reports and owner posts about it all over the forums.
As far as i know no one has ever pinpointed a definitive cause and solution to the problem but there have been several theories, ideas and changes folk have made to their machines in an effort to fix it one of which was the careful adjustment of the valve clearances. I`m sceptical on the effectiveness of what that alone would achieve.
These lethargic cranking events usually happen after a restart when the bike has only been ridden a mile or two or after the engine has been stopped immediately after a cold start - mine seems to have mild symptoms of the problem but does do it accasionally. It seems to have improved as its got more miles on it and the slow cranking - when it does happen - is only just noticeable now, earlier on in the bikes life the electronics would abort the starting attempt completely presumably after the battery voltage dipped to a certain level (with associated bogus warning messages on the TFT).

Does your bike exhibit the problem regularly?
If it does you could be the ideal candidate to prove - or disprove - the effectiveness of whether valve clearances are a factor, if it improves starting on your bike after adjustment then we could say it does help.
The problem is that the issue is so random and unpredictable as to when its going to happen that effective diagnosis make it difficult to find a solution.
The MHTX16 has has good reviews on here and has eliminated this hot start issue for at least a couple of folk who post here.

Had to abandon a two week trip by ten days last week!
Was it so bad that you couldnt carry on with the trip?
That sounds like an extreme case of the issue, sometimes giving the battery 10 minutes to recover or a jump start and the bike bike will fire right up like nothing happened..
 
Hi guys 🖐 first post

Had to abandon a two week trip by ten days last week!

Hot starting issues on the 2019 which seems to be a common issue with this years model?

I've had the bike since November and changed the battery (like for like) a couple of weeks after buying it and has been fine through the winter and a 1000 mile ride through Scotland only a few weeks ago with no issues whatsoever — someone recommended the Motobatt Hybrid MHTX16 CCA350 which is perfect for this hot starting issue and with a better lifespan than the Motobatt MBYZ16H CCA240 but there's been none in the UK for weeks now so waiting on a delivery from Italy, shame really, as I wasn't a million miles away from Italy at the time when it all started.

Point of the thread is if anyone is aware whether a Valve Clearance Adjustment would be beneficial for this issue please? As I feel like I need to double up on sorting the issue.

Cheers
I have the hybrid battery and since I swapped to that I have never had the hot start issue since and you can even here how it much more power the bike has when you start now, even after repeated short journeys as I live in a city.

I know Adam (Pukmeister) did his valve clearence as a belt and braces (he was the first on here to adopt the hybrid battery as well) and I believe he has had zero issues as well. I'm sure he will be along soon @Pukmeister

In fact if you search the forum you will see once people get this hybrid the problems goes away
 
My starting issues have disappeared since getting this battery.

Mine weren't particularly hot starting problems but more like repeat starting problems. It would start the first time when cold, with a laboured crank. Then, if I stopped it, it would crank really slowly and sometimes start but most times not, and give all the dash messages. Before, I used to keep it on trickle charge between rides, it still did it. I took a punt on the Motobatt after reading the experience of these guys. Since then I haven't used a trickle charger at all, and have had zero problems.

It's a 2023 1250GSA with about 6K miles. I don't think it's to do with a specific year or valve clearances. Mine wasn't really 100% right from new, it got worse. I told the dealer at the last service but he said there was nothing wrong, but that day it started ok. I could have taken it back under warranty but I'd have just been given the same battery again. I personally think it's battery issue.

There's another thing; when using GS-911 I could never complete a task without having to start the bike for low voltage (from new). Now I can, the voltage remains steady throughout.

Motobatt Hybrid is the way to go.
 
Mine was worse when new - and it did do it from new, but got better with miles.
Knowing BMW`s recent strive for profit margin it wouldn`t surprise me to hear that they went to their battery supplier (Varta?) and said `we want 100,000 batteries from you but don`t want to pay more than 10 Euros each for them` So they got their cheap batteries but built down to a price with reduced lead density in the plates, flimsy cases, cheapo internals and lesser performance. The standard fitment is only 12Ah to begin with..
 
As you have probably already realised this hot starting `characteristic` is well-known and there are reports and owner posts about it all over the forums.
As far as i know no one has ever pinpointed a definitive cause and solution to the problem but there have been several theories, ideas and changes folk have made to their machines in an effort to fix it one of which was the careful adjustment of the valve clearances. I`m sceptical on the effectiveness of what that alone would achieve.
These lethargic cranking events usually happen after a restart when the bike has only been ridden a mile or two or after the engine has been stopped immediately after a cold start - mine seems to have mild symptoms of the problem but does do it accasionally. It seems to have improved as its got more miles on it and the slow cranking - when it does happen - is only just noticeable now, earlier on in the bikes life the electronics would abort the starting attempt completely presumably after the battery voltage dipped to a certain level (with associated bogus warning messages on the TFT).

Does your bike exhibit the problem regularly?
If it does you could be the ideal candidate to prove - or disprove - the effectiveness of whether valve clearances are a factor, if it improves starting on your bike after adjustment then we could say it does help.
The problem is that the issue is so random and unpredictable as to when its going to happen that effective diagnosis make it difficult to find a solution.
The MHTX16 has has good reviews on here and has eliminated this hot start issue for at least a couple of folk who post here.


Was it so bad that you couldnt carry on with the trip?
That sounds like an extreme case of the issue, sometimes giving the battery 10 minutes to recover or a jump start and the bike bike will fire right up like nothing happened..
Cheers for your reply, it means a lot, thanks!

The first time it happened was on my second ride out when I bought it, as you say, only 2 miles down the road to fuel up and had to phone the RAC for a jump! A couple of checks and changed the battery for a like for like (naively). Like I say the new battery was fine through winter and Scotland, however it had another hissy fit in the Peak District a couple of weeks after Scotland and then fired back up after 20 minutes as others have mentioned.

Changed the oil to Motul 7100 5w40 which brought the volts up from a consistent 12.4v to a consistent 12.7v when the bike is not running and done a few tests two days before Europe and all was great! Reports of 13.2v on the Hybrid so this seems to be the way forwards on the issue, but all comes down to the CCA I believe...

Flying down the autobahn a few days later from the oil change (must have covered 200 miles without stopping) quick pitstop and that's then the issues re-emerged at the fuel station - reading 12.4v which is considered a half change. Must be these weak batteries
As you have probably already realised this hot starting `characteristic` is well-known and there are reports and owner posts about it all over the forums.
As far as i know no one has ever pinpointed a definitive cause and solution to the problem but there have been several theories, ideas and changes folk have made to their machines in an effort to fix it one of which was the careful adjustment of the valve clearances. I`m sceptical on the effectiveness of what that alone would achieve.
These lethargic cranking events usually happen after a restart when the bike has only been ridden a mile or two or after the engine has been stopped immediately after a cold start - mine seems to have mild symptoms of the problem but does do it accasionally. It seems to have improved as its got more miles on it and the slow cranking - when it does happen - is only just noticeable now, earlier on in the bikes life the electronics would abort the starting attempt completely presumably after the battery voltage dipped to a certain level (with associated bogus warning messages on the TFT).

Does your bike exhibit the problem regularly?
If it does you could be the ideal candidate to prove - or disprove - the effectiveness of whether valve clearances are a factor, if it improves starting on your bike after adjustment then we could say it does help.
The problem is that the issue is so random and unpredictable as to when its going to happen that effective diagnosis make it difficult to find a solution.
The MHTX16 has has good reviews on here and has eliminated this hot start issue for at least a couple of folk who post here.


Was it so bad that you couldnt carry on with the trip?
That sounds like an extreme case of the issue, sometimes giving the battery 10 minutes to recover or a jump start and the bike bike will fire right up like nothing happened..

Cheers for your reply, it means a lot, thanks!

The first time it happened was on my second ride out when I bought it, as you say, only 2 miles down the road to fuel up and had to phone the RAC for a jump! A couple of checks and changed the battery for a like for like (naively). Like I say the new battery was fine through winter and Scotland, however it had another hissy fit in the Peak District a couple of weeks after Scotland and then fired back up after 20 minutes as others have mentioned.

Changed the oil to Motul 7100 5w40 which brought the volts up from a consistent 12.4v to a consistent 12.7v when the bike is not running and done a few tests two days before Europe and all was great! Reports of 13.2v on the Hybrid so this seems to be the way forwards on the issue, but all comes down to the CCA I believe...

Flying down the autobahn a few days later from the oil change (must have covered 200 miles without stopping) quick pitstop and that's then the issues re-emerged at the fuel station - reading 12.4v which is considered a half change. So, it must be the battery?!

I'll contact Motobatt for a refund on the one I bought in November, so wish me luck.
Yes, hopefully my local tech can finetune the values if the new hybrid if it doesn't work.

Thanks again
 
I have the hybrid battery and since I swapped to that I have never had the hot start issue since and you can even here how it much more power the bike has when you start now, even after repeated short journeys as I live in a city.

I know Adam (Pukmeister) did his valve clearence as a belt and braces (he was the first on here to adopt the hybrid battery as well) and I believe he has had zero issues as well. I'm sure he will be along soon @Pukmeister

In fact if you search the forum you will see once people get this hybrid the problems goes away
Music to my eyes reading this, honestly, they seem to be a game changer.

Thanks very much!
 
Check out my thread called “Big Pile of Dogshit” in the 1250 section of the forum. It’s a lengthy thread but shows I was not alone in a failing battery/unreliable hot starting ‘19 plate bike.

I can’t say enough good things about the Motobatt Hybrid battery. It’s not cheap and as far as I can tell it’s the only battery of its type so far, there are some impressive videos online of it starting large American HGV’s from cold, such is its ability to deliver amps.
 
Mine weren't particularly hot starting problems but more like repeat starting problems. It would start the first time when cold, with a laboured crank. Then, if I stopped it, it would crank really slowly and sometimes start but most times not, and give all the dash messages.
100% the same issue.
Thanks for your feedback!
Mine was worse when new - and it did do it from new, but got better with miles.
Knowing BMW`s recent strive for profit margin it wouldn`t surprise me to hear that they went to their battery supplier (Varta?) and said `we want 100,000 batteries from you but don`t want to pay more than 10 Euros each for them` So they got their cheap batteries but built down to a price with reduced lead density in the plates, flimsy cases, cheapo internals and lesser performance. The standard fitment is only 12Ah to begin with..
Seems plausible.

Definitely feel more confident on the new hybrid battery after reading all your comments now 👍
 
Check out my thread called “Big Pile of Dogshit” in the 1250 section of the forum. It’s a lengthy thread but shows I was not alone in a failing battery/unreliable hot starting ‘19 plate bike.

I can’t say enough good things about the Motobatt Hybrid battery. It’s not cheap and as far as I can tell it’s the only battery of its type so far, there are some impressive videos online of it starting large American HGV’s from cold, such is its ability to deliver amps.
Thanks a lot Pukmeister, great content!

I actually read some of your posts on the matter, much appreciated.
 
To sum it all up:

The root cause of hot starting problems is exhaust VALVE CLEARANCE,
as mentioned in the past by someone, I don't remember who exactly.
I have had the problem too and it is a fact well known by BMW mechanics.

Have your exhaust valve clearance adjusted to the max value in the range and you will never face this issue again.

As a side note, I must add that I too have fitted a Motobatt hybrid. And boy oh boy, what a great battery! It is expensive, but it provides such higher levels of energy that the whole bike feels better. No more ticking under load, which I have noticed happens with lower voltage batteries. My voltage reading is 13.1v with engine off. Any stock battery physically cannot go above 12.4 or 12.5v, as you all know.

It is the best battery I have ever fitted to a motorcycle.
 
As you have probably already realised this hot starting `characteristic` is well-known and there are reports and owner posts about it all over the forums.
As far as i know no one has ever pinpointed a definitive cause and solution to the problem but there have been several theories, ideas and changes folk have made to their machines in an effort to fix it one of which was the careful adjustment of the valve clearances. I`m sceptical on the effectiveness of what that alone would achieve.
These lethargic cranking events usually happen after a restart when the bike has only been ridden a mile or two or after the engine has been stopped immediately after a cold start - mine seems to have mild symptoms of the problem but does do it accasionally. It seems to have improved as its got more miles on it and the slow cranking - when it does happen - is only just noticeable now, earlier on in the bikes life the electronics would abort the starting attempt completely presumably after the battery voltage dipped to a certain level (with associated bogus warning messages on the TFT).

Does your bike exhibit the problem regularly?
If it does you could be the ideal candidate to prove - or disprove - the effectiveness of whether valve clearances are a factor, if it improves starting on your bike after adjustment then we could say it does help.
The problem is that the issue is so random and unpredictable as to when its going to happen that effective diagnosis make it difficult to find a solution.
The MHTX16 has has good reviews on here and has eliminated this hot start issue for at least a couple of folk who post here.


Was it so bad that you couldnt carry on with the trip?
That sounds like an extreme case of the issue, sometimes giving the battery 10 minutes to recover or a jump start and the bike bike will fire right up like nothing happened..
I bought an R1250gsa Rallye HP in Oct 24, stored over winter, bought a Motobatt MBYZ16H two weeks ago to prevent any nonsense with these warm engine starting problems. Left a campsite in North Yorkshire rode around 10 miles stopping for petrol and bike refused to start whilst stationary at the pump ! Pushed a fully laden bike ( 3box luggage plus 80 litre Ortlieb bag on pillion seat) to side of the forecourt, a mate pushed me on bike three times to try and bump it, but nothing. Buggered about phoning and panicking as I was 220 miles from home, after around 40 mins pressed starter and it fired, so rode the entire distance to home without stopping. Have now returned above battery to Motobatt and will go for MHTX16 with 350cca, hopefully that will stop this happening again. What a bastard, never ever had this crap happen with any BM over 30years !!
 
@Scotdick

The root cause of hot starting problems is exhaust VALVE CLEARANCE.

Have your exhaust valve clearance adjusted to the max value in the range and you will never face this issue again.

If you do not, you WILL face the issue again, whichever battery you fit to your motorcycle.
 
@Scotdick

The root cause of hot starting problems is exhaust VALVE CLEARANCE.

Have your exhaust valve clearance adjusted to the max value in the range and you will never face this issue again.

If you do not, you WILL face the issue again, whichever battery you fit to your motorcycle.arting

You are assuming that this is a 'hot starting" issue. For which, if not, your solution may be the root cause. But in reality it's not really 'hot' start, it's multiple starts. If you try to start it 2 times in a row, even when cold, it struggles to start again though battery drain. The OEM batteries that are supplied aren't really up to the game. The better battery solves this issue without the need for further work. Mine was like this from being brand new, until fitting the new battery.
 
You are assuming that this is a 'hot starting" issue. For which, if not, your solution may be the root cause. But in reality it's not really 'hot' start, it's multiple starts. If you try to start it 2 times in a row, even when cold, it struggles to start again though battery drain. The OEM batteries that are supplied aren't really up to the game. The better battery solves this issue without the need for further work. Mine was like this from being brand new, until fitting the new battery.
You're right about those weak batteries, which is why I am also running an MHTX16 Hybrid from Motobatt.
And you're also right about the fact that I am assuming he has hot starting issues, because this is what he describes and this is the thread dedicated to this problem :)

I think he might get even more frustrated if the battery doesn't solve his issue. Which it did not for me when I was in his situation :)
Only talking from my own miserable experience with that not so well known solution to this frequently encountered issue.
 
You are assuming that this is a 'hot starting" issue. For which, if not, your solution may be the root cause. But in reality it's not really 'hot' start, it's multiple starts. If you try to start it 2 times in a row, even when cold, it struggles to start again though battery drain. The OEM batteries that are supplied aren't really up to the game. The better battery solves this issue without the need for further work. Mine was like this from being brand new, until fitting the new battery.
Oh, 2 more things :
1. It is not "my" solution, it is BMW's. And it "may" not be the root cause. It is the official and actual root cause of weak starts (apart from a dead battery or starter, obviously), which is easily addressed via valve adjustment
2. The issue also exists when cold, hence the starting problem after one attempt. It is just less prominent because the parts are not dilated yet. But it is there. A more powerful battery will overcome the problem when cold, but might not when hot. Hence the frustration that I was mentioning before, which I have faced. On the other hand, after adjusting the valves and with the same crappy stock battery, I assure you that you can start it several times in a row in front of your garage door if you so wish. I know, because I have tried!

As I always say, I have nothing to sell :) And I don't wish to argue for the sake of arguing. I actually dislike that a lot.
I am only trying to help because I have been through all this. And I am lucky enough to have a VERY competent BMW dealer who knows just about every little issue of every BMW motorcycle since the mid 90's and loves educating his customers.
 
Post number 9 sums it up. Mine was definitely not the valves.

Listen, I don't doubt that wrong valve settings would cause a problem, but just not in my case.
 
I am lucky enough to have a VERY competent BMW dealer who knows just about every little issue of every BMW motorcycle
Don`t see how valve clearance can make such a dramatic effect unless your mechanic thinks it`s the relationship between the valve gap and the effectiveness of the decompressor mechanism?
 
Indeed, it doesn't sound like the valve clearance adjustment going off what I've learnt recently, good call though, merely the lower CCA is just way Way WAY too weak for the GSA from the OEM battery. Would potentially save you a small fortune going with the latter, too... Had to order mine from Italy as there wasn't any in the UK last month 😄 good luck!
 


Back
Top Bottom