Latest Helmet Test Results

Vern

Toy maker
UKGSer Subscriber
Joined
Jan 3, 2002
Messages
5,429
Reaction score
82
Location
A bit south of Chester
I get all this bumpf from the DfT as and when it gets released, and it makes some interesting reading.

Arai are good then:rolleyes:

I'm happy I've been using Shoei helmets for the last umpteen years.

No results for the Tour X, and the flip fronts don't look to clever either.

Here you go, knock yourselves out(literally:D)

http://sharp.direct.gov.uk/
 
It is intresting to see how a helmet which costs less than £100 can have better protection than one costing 4 times that. It is asked did they ask for samples or did they just purchase randomly :rolleyes:

I have been using Shoei for the last 5 years and always thought they were exellent

Arai ! not 1 helmet with 5 stars :eek:

Flip helmets which i use only two get 5 stars one of which was the BMW system five which i tried and i was fein horrible and the Scuberth which is suposed to be the best :rolleyes: with 3 stars for the best part of £400 :eek:

Intresting

Jim:thumb
 
Hmm...

So my Schuberth S1 Pro that cost an arm and leg and was written up as a good lid gets 2 stars !! and a £70 Nitro lid gets 5 stars...

Think I'll just get a 5 star rated £100 lid every year on Jan 1st in sales and bin it on Dec 31st..
 
Samples bought randomly from bike shops, so no chance of getting a "Fixed" helmet on the test.

I don't normally pay much attention to this sort of thing, but this one seems to be fairly well thought out.
 
it makes some interesting reading.

http://sharp.direct.gov.uk/

Thanks for this - fascinating.
Word of caution, though...there's a HUGE row about the Sharp testing, as to whether it's worth squat or not.
Now you might think that Arai, for example, who can charge you £600 for a lid would cry foul when beaten for safety by lids costing £80, and fair enough.
But it's also worth thinking that however much people pay for the name when they buy an Arai or Shoei etc, what's thing actually made of, how much research has gone in to the build, does the company actually have a test facility (don't laugh, HJC's cost $6.4m to build when they decided to sponsor Ben Spies are luanch top end stuff). Point is those top end lids are engineered to be as good as possible. Whether they're worth £600 is a different question. They're not churned out to be cheap, whereas your Box effort is.
How many of Sharp's high-rated low price lids would get an ACU Gold Sticker? None. So are ACU idiots, or are they testing different things?
I'm not saying either side is right, but it'll take quite a lot for me to stick my head in a budget lid on the say-so of a bunch of civil servants....

(*goes out again in crap old Shark MX lid and goggles, like yesterday*)
 
Just looked up Nolan N103 not as bad as I thought it would be as its a flip front.
Well it got 4 to off 5 :augie
As a paramedic said to me 'Hitting anything at 60mph is going to hurt you regardless off what you wear.' :( :augie
 
ACU gold sticker means absolutley nothing at all, to anyone, anywhere. The ACU sell them to anyone who wants to buy them for about 90p each. All you need is some sort of helmet to tell the ACU about, and they'll sell you the stickers.

Don't you remember the big scandal about it?
 
I don't, no. That's yet more interesting.
I suppose my difficulty with the Sharp things is trying to understand it from a business point of view - i.e. someone like Box tries to keep R&D and manufacturing costs as close to zero as possible, in order to sell lids very cheaply. Arai don't, in fact they do the opposite, so how can the one turn out safer than the other?
 
I remember someone telling me one of the reason the Arai tend to get poor score is one of the tests is on the side of the helmet is done at a point where Arai use less material so get poor score for impact on this area but there own test show this spot doesn't get damaged in a crash,

where as the cheaper stuff has the same thickness of material overall so they get better scores

?
 
And where do you and me buy custom, factory made to measure £4000 lids then:rolleyes:

The thing with testing anything, is you have to have a benchmark, and submit everything to the same punishment, and then publish the results.

It's up to everyone else to work out how they read the results, and if they trust or believe them or not.

Simples:thumb2
 
why are motorcross helmets not tested on the sharp test? as me and my girl friend use them on the road.


plus my old Arai helmet had 2 stars and when i came off at 30mph it went down to the wire and went in the bin.
 


Back
Top Bottom