Thanks guys, always get a lot of personal preference in these things.
I used Roadsmart 1'2, 2's on a few bikes and really liked them, I have RS3's on my KTM 1190, certainly not a bad tyre, but they are a bit long in the tooth in a world that changes fast, the Ride Wet Tyre Test had them 6th out of 8, but 4-6th were very close, the Bridgestone T31, Michelin Road 5 and Metzeler Sportec 01 were also very close in 1st - 3rd but seemed a cut above the rest.
The problem is this is one riders opinion, and only tested on one bike - would of been better had they got 3-4 riders trying them all as the Motorrad tests used to. Also with the Michelin our sizes (KTM Adventure / BMW GS) are different with a "trail" in the name, not sure what changes they made, probably stiffer carcass as they assume we all ride heavy BMW's and not light KTM's
As for old tyres, I had the Tourance Next on my KTM 1090 last year and got caught in one of the heaviest rain showers I have ever ridden in and they felt excellent, I have never felt so confident in the wet, but the 1090 is a different bike, the suspension feels very different to the 1190 and it sits on skinnier tyres, so for all I know they would of felt awful on the 1190?
I guess each person rides differently and a tyre that gives good feedback to some folk will feel wooden to others.
Will probably go with the Michelin as it is not getting lots of complaints, and although I find the Roadsmart 3 OK in the cold and wet I am not convinced it is any better than the 1 or 2 in cold and wet conditions.