New Shad SH35 panniers now fitted

fred_jb

Registered user
Joined
Feb 26, 2017
Messages
1,508
Reaction score
10
Location
Loughborough, England
Some of you may have seen my thread a few months ago where I fitted Shad panniers, which involved fitting a low level exhaust (from an R1200 RT) to my GS. At the time I couldn't get the new Shad SH35 panniers which I wanted, so got a deal on some ex-display older style SH36 ones which I fitted for our summer tour of Spain and Portugal.

I've now bought a set of the new SH35 panniers which I prefer the look of and which are flatter sided, so a bit slimmer, which I confirmed when I checked them out at the NEC show, though they lose a little capacity, being 35 litres v 36 litres. The older ones when fitted ended up a little wider than the bars, but the new ones are 980 mm across when fitted, which is exactly the same width as the bars. This has satisfied my perfectionist tendencies even though I could filter perfectly well with the old ones! I prefer the appearance of the new ones, and I think the aluminium panel suits the bike better and balances out the aluminium panel over the forks at the front, but would be interested to know if you think it is an improvement - one or two people were less than complimentary about the old ones!

This gives me a total storage capacity of 128 litres, 70 for the two panniers and 58 for the adjustable top box when set in its largest position. I was interested to read that the new Honda Goldwing has only 110 litres, compared with 150 for the old model. Apparently this continent crossing bike is mainly used for 2-3 day trips according to Honda's market research, so they decided that 110 litres would be sufficient! So as a tourer I think my bike is far superior - it weighs 135 kg less than the Goldwing, has the same maximum power, 18 litres more luggage capacity, and has self leveling suspension whereas the Goldwing has manually selectable presets for rear preload, like the previous GS.

Fred

New panniers:

A6K-3047129-6089-X2.jpg


Old panniers:

A6K-3047129-5711-X2.jpg
 
The Shad website now shows the panniers available for the GS LC with the standard silencer, but I'm not sure how wide the bike would be with the panniers fitted

http://www.shad.es/es/shad-world/productos/fijaciones/bmw/r1200-gs/2016/c12mar12mod249mot4250/

When I first got them, and before doing any mods, I fitted mine with the standard exhaust just to see what they were like, and the right side was obviously quite wide to clear the exhaust, but the left side was also quite a long way out from the side of the bike, presumably to make the installation more symmetrical. Unfortunately I didn't make a note of the actual width, but the picture should give you an idea. I am sure they will be wider than the BMW Vario panniers as there is no cutout for the exhaust in the right hand pannier.

A6K-3047129-5591-X3.jpg


This is how it looks now after fitting the lowered exhaust and moving the panniers as close to the side of the bike as possible, by a mixture of modifying the Shad mounting hardware and fabricating new bits. In the end I didn't use the Shad mounting rails that came with the GS LC fitting kit, but used the ones which came with the SH36 panniers (they came with a mounting kit intended for the Yamaha MT-09) as the front lower mounting piece on these was easier to mod to fit in the new location. The SH35 panniers shown below come out about 30 mm narrower overall than the SH36 ones I used initially. Both fit on the same mounting rails.

A6K-3047129-6084-X3.jpg



Fred
 
Has anyone fitted a Shad plate to an Adventure rather than a standard GS? I'm told it bolts straight onto the rack but I can't seem to figure out the alignment.
 
Sorry, but I'm not familiar with the GSA rack so don't know the answer. If it helps, with the GS there are two triangular steel adapter plates from Shad which bolt to the bike's rack. The plastic mounting plate for the top box then bolts to these plates. Under the removable cover on the plastic plate there are a multitude of positions where the four fixing bolts could go, but you need to use the ones which line up with the two tapped and two drilled holes in the steel adapter plates.
 
Shad make the S1000XR panniers for BMW.

The second panniers are a really neat fit - a good look too.

They'll be a lot lighter than Varios.

Thanks - it was a lot of work adapting the mounts, but worth it to me for more luggage capacity and a narrower bike. I was also able to incorporate a couple of tool tubes which are useful for carrying 1 litre petrol and 350 ml oil containers plus a few extra tools.

The Shad panniers are very light, but also totally waterproof and very strong - proved in an incident on a previous bike in the Pyrenees. I was avoiding the edge of the road where it was crumbling and so when a car coming the other way cut the corner I was unable to totally avoid it and the offside pannier hit the car door. The car door was dented but there was no serious damage to the pannier and no damage at all to the mounting rail. There was a mark on the plastic from the contact, but a couple of coats of Halfords black bumper paint and it was as good as new. I suspect a Vario pannier would be more likely to break in a similar situation.
 
My vote is for the 35`s - reflects your engineering skills as well.
The original mounts diminish what could have been a real option against the varios.
 
My vote is for the 35`s - reflects your engineering skills as well.
The original mounts diminish what could have been a real option against the varios.

Thanks Bem. The problem with the original mounts is that they have to allow for the high level exhaust. The Varios accommodate this, but only at the cost of reduced space and an awkward internal shape for the right side pannier.

If Shad had a bit more ambition they could maybe produce a kit including a low level exhaust can and modified mounts optimised for that, but maybe the limited demand would not make it worthwhile. They also manufacture a lot of BMW's panniers so perhaps wouldn't want to antagonise them.
 


Back
Top Bottom