NIKWAX v STORM v GRAINGER - which is the best waterproofer?

[Andy B]

Two questions here really:

1. Does anyone have strong views on which of these three brands make the best products?

2. If I were to choose a heat-curing one (i.e iron or tumble-dry for a better waterproof finish) will I reduce the jacket's ability to breath properly?

All comments (on-topic!) gratefully received!

 

[Mav]

Two questions here really:

1. Does anyone have strong views on which of these three brands make the best products?

2. If I were to choose a heat-curing one (i.e iron or tumble-dry for a better waterproof finish) will I reduce the jacket's ability to breath properly?

All comments (on-topic!) gratefully received!

Doesn't it depend a great deal on the material you're waterproofing?

 

[Bikerbuk]

Used Nikwax many times on my paramo gear. Always had a good result, never tried the others.

 

[Deleted account 230818001]

I've tried Nikwax and Grainger's, very similar results but the Grainger's is an all in one, so no need to use a separate cleaning product first.

 

[kevtherev]

I've just used Storm on my Rukka Arma S because it was wetting out - though not leaking. It's not rained yet so the jury's out but it must be good stuff because Rukka UK recommend it for their products and I can't imagine they'd do this if was naff stuff.