Tank bag recommendation

None of them, they're all a faff which is why i stopped using them.

If you do have to have one then a tanklock is probably the easiest.
Exactly my thoughts on tank bags. There’s a couple of the lads who come on our annual trips have them. They have to take them off and carry them about whenever we stop for a wander around or park the bikes out of sight. I certainly couldn’t be bothered with having to carry a handbag around. Everything i need to hand is in my pockets.
 
Exactly my thoughts on tank bags. There’s a couple of the lads who come on our annual trips have them. They have to take them off and carry them about whenever we stop for a wander around or park the bikes out of sight. I certainly couldn’t be bothered with having to carry a handbag around. Everything i need to hand is in my pockets.
Or you could just put the locking pin in, nearly put my back out doing it and snapping the padlock shut mind you. Saves on me having to carry my pump, sockets, tyre plugger kit, multitool and visor cleaning kit. That tab you have to pull to release it at a petrol station can be a real inconvenience though. :LOL:
 
Or you could just put the locking pin in, nearly put my back out doing it and snapping the padlock shut mind you. Saves on me having to carry my pump, sockets, tyre plugger kit, multitool and visor cleaning kit. That tab you have to pull to release it at a petrol station can be a real inconvenience though. :LOL:
Not sure there is a locking pin on their magnetic tank bags but you seem to be sure. I’ll ask them why they carry all that crap around instead of the locking pin. All that crap you have in your tank bag is in the bottom of my panniers. The weight is much lower down that way. I hardly need the tyre plugger so immediately available. After all I will be getting off if I have a puncture.
 
Not sure there is a locking pin on their magnetic tank bags but you seem to be sure. I’ll ask them why they carry all that crap around instead of the locking pin. All that crap you have in your tank bag is in the bottom of my panniers. The weight is much lower down that way. I hardly need the tyre plugger so immediately available. After all I will be getting off if I have a puncture.
I dont ride around with panniers on everyday, 2 bikes, just take the tank bag across from one to the other depending on what im riding day to day and always have my kit with me. The one day I didnt take the puncture kit was you might of guessed is the one day I got a puncture and had 5 hours waiting for BMW recovery due to being on a Sunday evening. Hate the look of tank bags but it just works and is convenient. You can buy the SW Motech kit(as on the last pic) or you can just buy your own ball pin for a few quid and a padlock. The pin stops you being able to pull the cord to release the bag. I know givi have some bags with an actual key lock and I think Rhinowalk do now but I'm all in with SW Motech tankrings and rear plate.

Previously had the SW Motech tool box which fits to pannier frames and the Wunderlich one too but I now have the quick release pannier frames and no frames at all on the R12 so again the tank bag is the easiest solution for day to day riding.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3769.JPG
    IMG_3769.JPG
    362.7 KB · Views: 19
  • IMG_3770.jpg
    IMG_3770.jpg
    334 KB · Views: 11
  • IMG_3771.jpg
    IMG_3771.jpg
    401.9 KB · Views: 10
  • IMG_3772.JPG
    IMG_3772.JPG
    388.5 KB · Views: 11
  • Screenshot 2026-08-31 at 16.44.46.jpg
    Screenshot 2026-08-31 at 16.44.46.jpg
    119.8 KB · Views: 18
Not sure there is a locking pin on their magnetic tank bags but you seem to be sure. I’ll ask them why they carry all that crap around instead of the locking pin. All that crap you have in your tank bag is in the bottom of my panniers. The weight is much lower down that way. I hardly need the tyre plugger so immediately available. After all I will be getting off if I have a puncture.
Definitely no pin on the magnetic tank bags - only on the tank-ring types where the ring is screwed to the bike. The optional SM-Motech locking kit comes with the locking pin - though you have to drill the hole for it - and a combination lock to go the the zips.
I certainly don't want to carry the bag around with me
 
I’m definitely leaning towards the SW Motech but I see what you mean. My screws are hidden under the flap too.
I have the SW Motech tank ring on my R12 and I’m almost certain it’s the same tank ring I had on my Urban GS.. I know I didn’t go out and buy a new one…
 
I have the SW Motech tank ring on my R12 and I’m almost certain it’s the same tank ring I had on my Urban GS.. I know I didn’t go out and buy a new one…
I did get the SW Motech Yukon bag and their offset tank ring. Just come back from a trip and it worked well.
 

Attachments

  • 57648ac9-2d01-482c-b428-0d24de1b4f99.jpeg
    57648ac9-2d01-482c-b428-0d24de1b4f99.jpeg
    629.7 KB · Views: 13


Back
Top Bottom