TomTom takes Garmin to court (again)

ebbo

Registered user
Joined
Feb 21, 2003
Messages
7,146
Reaction score
9
Location
York
Quote...

TomTom, the Dutch navigation specialist, is taking US rival Garmin to court in The Hague on Thursday. The company claims that Garmin is copying the look and feel of its GPS based portable navigation systems. :rolleyes:

Garmin and TomTom are chief rivals in the booming car navigation market. TomTom has a 30 per cent market share in Europe, while Garmin is at 16.7 per cent. In the US, Gsrmin leads with 50.8 per cent, with TomTom on 26.9 per cent.

Earlier this year, Garmin claimed that TomTom had infringed five US-patented Garmin technologies designed to "calculate which streets are important enough to a driver’s route to be displayed."

In March TomTom responded with a counter-claim that Garmin infringed three of its patents. A jury trial isn't expected until February 2007.

In August Garmin filed a second patent infringement lawsuit against TomTom, so obviously the Dutch company had to strike back - although this time not with patent claims. Details of the complaints were not released.

TomTom decline to comment on the case "until further notice".

Garmin International spokesman Ted Gartner declined to discuss the specifics of the case, but he told The Register: "We can say that Garmin is confident that its personal navigational devices do not infringe any design rights of TomTom and looks forward to a prompt and decisive ruling from the District Court of The Hague vindicating its position." ®

source of information (slow to load)
 
ill use garmin ever :thumb y time.surely they can both have a slice of the cake.
 
'Quote'
Surely they can both have a slice of the cake :eek:

I don’t think it works like that, they both want it all :D
 
ebbo said:
I don’t think it works like that, they both want it all :D
Neither of them will get it.

TomTom will be the big looser in the short perspective. Take a look at the new Nokia N95 and you will understand that the market will change fast.

Garmin will survive longer, at least for motorbike applications, because of it's route planning software MapSource and because if their status as industry standard within more advanced applications.

Within a year or so Nokia, Ericsson, Samsung and the other phone developers will flood the market with GPS phones filled with functionality far better than TomTom but at much lower price & size. The day when they come up with route planning software it will be goodbye also for Garmin. :eek:

Just wait and see! We, the users, are the winners! :thumb
 
I've always been a pesimist... :rob

HMR said:
Just wait and see! We, the users, are the winners! :thumb
Though will the like of Nokia et al. bother to manufaturer units for niche markets such as ours. Garmin may still be around for that but prices will probably reflect the significantly deminished market share. Rather than being a producer of GPS units they'll become a producer of specialist GPS units.
 
ebbo said:
'Quote'
Surely they can both have a slice of the cake :eek:

I don’t think it works like that, they both want it all :D
Hmm, reminds me of a few well known software companies, world domination maybe?
 
Mouse said:
Standard business practice these days really. Allege your competitor has infringed your patents, in return they allege you infringed theirs.
When Caterham took kit-car manufacturer Westfield to court for infringement of copyright (and won), the market in second-hand Westfields was instantly lifted as people recognised what a good copy it was!

Greg
 
HMR said:
Neither of them will get it.

TomTom will be the big looser in the short perspective. Take a look at the new Nokia N95 and you will understand that the market will change fast.

Garmin will survive longer, at least for motorbike applications, because of it's route planning software MapSource and because if their status as industry standard within more advanced applications.

Within a year or so Nokia, Ericsson, Samsung and the other phone developers will flood the market with GPS phones filled with functionality far better than TomTom but at much lower price & size. The day when they come up with route planning software it will be goodbye also for Garmin. :eek:

Just wait and see! We, the users, are the winners! :thumb
as long as the quality remains the same
 
Greg Masters said:
When Caterham took kit-car manufacturer Westfield to court for infringement of copyright (and won), the market in second-hand Westfields was instantly lifted as people recognised what a good copy it was!

Greg
ill have a cossack please
 
ovenpaa said:
Hmm, reminds me of a few well known software companies, world domination maybe?
i dont know who you mean ?
 


Back
Top Bottom