Varios to GSA panniers?

[Big Lee]

Hi Folks,

I`m seriously considering changing my varios for the big box GSA panniers and was wondering if the GSA frames can be fitted to a 12 "sport" GS and still keep the rear rack. I`ve got a nice TT rack extension and I`d like to keep it as it`s handy. Also are the GSA boxes as easy to remove and fix on as the varios?

Cheers

Lee

 

[andyclift]

Also are the GSA boxes as easy to remove and fix on as the varios?

Yes they are plus I think the top opening panniers are MUCH more practical

 

[Big Lee]

I agree about the top opening

 

[tunnie]

only problem with ali panniers is they are not as water tight as Varios

 

[MIKE R]

only problem with ali panniers is they are not as water tight as Varios

...........and they corrode at the first sign of salt

 

[Big Lee]

not as watertight? it`s a big alloy box, how hard is it to make watertight!!

Anyway it looks like this idea is down the pan since this afternoon my bike decided it liked 6th gear and has stayed there much clutch slip on the way home and another bike split bill in 6 months

 

[andyclift]

I have never had a problem with water entering my GSA panniers.

The corrosion on the GSAs is annoying, they should be supplied anodised. On the last bike I changed the Varios for Touratech Zega and to start with tried hard to keep the original shiny finish. Eventually I gave up and after a while the horrible spot marks all run together to result in a dull grey pannier which just has a well used look.

Incidentally, the Varios used to leak badly.

 

[Nice 'n' Fat]

not as watertight? it`s a big alloy box, how hard is it to make watertight!!

You've never owned a Defender have you?

 

[tunnie]

...........and they corrode at the first sign of salt

my 56 plate is on 36k miles the panniers look like new, i wrap things in bags for the side panniers, so i don't find side opening an issue

 

[GSband]

Hi Folks,

I`m seriously considering changing my varios for the big box GSA panniers and was wondering if the GSA frames can be fitted to a 12 "sport" GS and still keep the rear rack. I`ve got a nice TT rack extension and I`d like to keep it as it`s handy. Also are the GSA boxes as easy to remove and fix on as the varios?

Cheers

Lee

First, yes, the GSA frames can be fitted on a GS.
But, take a look at pictures from GS and GSA (on BMW website, e.g.). You'll notice end rack differs. Standard GS end rack must be removed, GSA end rack installed to fasten a GSA aluminium topcase.

Hope this answers your questions.

My GS has the Vario boxes. Never had a problem with water. Happy with them. 114000km on 2 R12GS.

 

[Big Lee]

Answers my questions perfectly! Thanks