Vibration at 5000 rpm - 2014 GS TE

Billy Big Roy

Active member
UKGSer Subscriber
Joined
Dec 1, 2014
Messages
152
Reaction score
0
Location
Oxfordshire
Hi all, I picked up a June 2014 GS TE just over a week ago with 948 miles on it. I didn't test ride my bike as it was in the showroom, so test rode 3 other GS TE's just to make sure I was making the right choice as I had wanted a S1000R as a daily commuter. 2 were from the same dealer, the 3rd from another.

I picked the GS over the R as it seemed a great all round bike and perfect for my daily 126 mile commute, and I was very impressed with the demo bikes.

On riding home from the dealers, I noticed the bike would vibrate badly at 5000 rpm, with the vibration starting to come in at 4500 rpm. Its so bad you can feel it through the seat and frame. I thought this may be because I had some accessories I had purchased in the top box.

By the time I had ridden the 44 miles home, I couldn't feel the finger tips in my left hand, and my backside was numb, almost to the point I was in pain.

I removed the panniers the following day, then didn't use the bike for a few days. I went to visit my parents, but they only live a few miles away from me. The bike did feel better, but I didn't managed to get it up to speed on that journey due to traffic and the weather.

Two days later, I made the dummy run to my office in Hemel Hempstead. 126 mile round trip. The bike vibrated so much, at 75 - 80 mph you couldn't see out of the rear mirrors they vibrated that bad. The seat and frame felt like I was having a mild electric shock put through my body. It would be impossible to ride the bike daily, covering those miles with the level of vibration.

I took the bike back to the dealers and was told "thats what a GS rides like". I asked why the demo didn't ride like that then, or the other bikes I had rode, but got no real explanation. I pointed out that I did not feel BMW would design a "world touring" bike that costs over £14k to ride the way mine does. Again, no real explanation.

I felt totally fobbed off, so booked the bike in to my local dealer. I drop it off later so it be looked at tomorrow.

Since I booked the bike in to another dealer, the suppling dealer asked me to take the bike to them yesterday to be looked at, so I spend nearly 3 hours there yesterday.

We tried a number of things, first thing was to remove the engine protection bars as this I was told my impacted on the harmonics of the frame. They did this, I then took it out on the road. No change at all, so they were put back on.

Next was to fit wheels and tyres from another bike on to mine. These were fitted with Conti tyres. I must admit, these did help, but only slightly. Below 3500 rpm, it felt smoother, and it moved the point the vibration comes in up by 300 rpm to 4800 rpm. It didn't totally cure it though.

Next was to complete a full bike reset, setting all the parameters back to factory. The saleman then took the bike out, and came back saying the vibration had gone! I was chuffed to bits, so suited up, thank them for all there effort and support and left for the ride home.

The vibration is still there. No change what so ever...Nothing. Totally gutted and disappointed.

I totally understand the bike has a BIG flat twin, and these aren't the smoothest of motors. I didn't purchase a Ducati as it wasn't for me.

NONE of the 3 demo bikes I rode vibrated like mine. If they had, I wouldn't of purchased a GS, I would of gone for the R, my original choice.

I'm not sure what to do? Reject the bike? Change the tyres?

The dealer is trying to resolve the issue, but if I'm honest, I do still feel like I'm not being taken seriously.

Any help and advice would be much appreciated. :thumb
 
Chris, your best option may be to get the dealer to swap your bike for one of their demo bikes. If you're not happy, you have a certain time period to reject the bike. Do it. This is not right.
 
I did think about this, but I really didn't want the hassle just before Christmas. I've even thought about buying a new Alpine GS TE just to start all over again with owning one. This time, I would ensure I ride the bike I'm buying!

I read the information re the BMW 30 day exchange policy, and the bike has to have a recognised fault to exercise the right to exchange / get a refund. I suppose by default, by working on the bike and offering to change the tyres yesterday, they have confirmed the bike has a "fault".
 
When my contact at Vines gets round to calling me, we'll get a second opinion.:thumb You're bike isn't right, and it needs sorting.
 
Definitely not right, take it back, and start the return process. Don't put it off. Always always test ride.!
 
Is the dealer open today?

If so get on the blower to the Salesman & make his day

Tell him you've given them chance to sort it

They haven't

So you are rejecting it & invoking the 30 day clause

Don't delay & piss about thinking of solutions

The clock is ticking ;)
 
Vibration

I had a late model twin cam adventure doing the same, mint bike low miles great ride no oil consumption, so wanted to keep it, and foolishly did,,,,
It had a set of wheels and a final drive with marginal improvement,
The mirrors and screen adjusters would work loose on long trips , I had the foam grip puppies which made it bearable with thick gloves,
but the 4 to 5000 rpm vibe especially acellerating was bad,,
I got rid after approx 16 months gutted,,
My 15 my gs doesn't vibrate and if in comparison to the demo bike yours does , you have covered your perception of the vibration by doing so,
I agree with nuttys advice and push to reject it,,, good luck,
Roamer
 
I agree with the above just take it back and return under your statuary rights, don't waist time with attempts to fix if there clueless to the problem.

One question when you took it back did they try to synchronise the throttle bodies !
 
+1 , Go to salesman or the manager,
Is the dealer open today?

If so get on the blower to the Salesman & make his day

Tell him you've given them chance to sort it

They haven't

So you are rejecting it & invoking the 30 day clause

Don't delay & piss about thinking of solutions

The clock is ticking ;)
 
You felt that you were being 'fobbed off' because you were being fobbed off, the bike is faulty, like others on here I'm riding my second GS-LC and both bikes have been great, and as a yardstick the mirrors remain pretty damn at all speeds and all revs.

Don't delay, take it back and have them fix it!
 
I agree with the above just take it back and return under your statuary rights, don't waist time with attempts to fix if there clueless to the problem.

One question when you took it back did they try to synchronise the throttle bodies !

No, they didn't synchronise the throttle bodies. I mentioned this, but was informed this was on the "earlier models" not mine.
 
Is the dealer open today?

If so get on the blower to the Salesman & make his day

Tell him you've given them chance to sort it

They haven't

So you are rejecting it & invoking the 30 day clause

Don't delay & piss about thinking of solutions

The clock is ticking ;)


No, they aren't open on a Sunday.

A BIG thank you for all your replies.

Sadly, you are right, I need to reside myself to the fact the bike is faulty, can't be fixed and needs to be returned. Gutted really as I really like the bike.

I've had a number of accessories fitted, LED riding lights, quick shifter and alarm. These were fitted before I collected the bike by the suppling dealer. With the 30 day clause, will I be reimbursed / should I expect to be reimbursed for the cost of these?

I will email the dealer tonight and update the thread tomorrow.
 
What was your suspension setting by chance?

I had a vibe at those revs on holiday. Took it to a dealer in Germany and they said it was because I had settings as one up with luggage. This raised the bike up quite a bit and because I only had a roll bag there was not enough weight to bring the bike down again.

It increased the angle from the gearbox to drive shaft causing the vibration. I dropped it down to just one rider no luggage and vibration gone.

Might be worth checking the settings to see and if so put it back and try it again.

Good luck :thumb2

Jon
 
What was your suspension setting by chance?

I had a vibe at those revs on holiday. Took it to a dealer in Germany and they said it was because I had settings as one up with luggage. This raised the bike up quite a bit and because I only had a roll bag there was not enough weight to bring the bike down again.

It increased the angle from the gearbox to drive shaft causing the vibration. I dropped it down to just one rider no luggage and vibration gone.

Might be worth checking the settings to see and if so put it back and try it again.

Good luck :thumb2

Jon

Hi Jon, my settings are at one crash helmet. Most of the time the bikes in ROAD mode, with the suspension at NORMAL. I tried riding with it set at SOFT, but it made no difference.
 
No, they aren't open on a Sunday.

A BIG thank you for all your replies.

Sadly, you are right, I need to reside myself to the fact the bike is faulty, can't be fixed and needs to be returned. Gutted really as I really like the bike.

I've had a number of accessories fitted, LED riding lights, quick shifter and alarm. These were fitted before I collected the bike by the suppling dealer. With the 30 day clause, will I be reimbursed / should I expect to be reimbursed for the cost of these?

I will email the dealer tonight and update the thread tomorrow.

As you're rejecting the bike, they'll have to remove any accessories, and fit them to the replacement bike.:thumb
 


Back
Top Bottom