Don't be put off by the design, you don't miss the extra fingers and for the money (£35?) they kept we warm and dry through all sorts of foul weather and snow at motorway speeds.
I have some old BMW ones Pro: Warm, Dry - Con: Bulky, Palms get hot with heated grips but tops still cold.
I tried the Panthan 'Lobster' Pro: Warm, Dry - Con: Never got comfortable using them. Same issue with heated grips.
I now use muffs and summer gloves. Pro: Warm, Dry, Have full 'feel', don't get cold tops of hands - Con: Muffs are bulky to store on the bike if you need to take them off (to stop them getting pinched)
I only have the muffs if I know I'm going on a long(ish) ride in the cold. Otherwise at this time of year I wear summer gloves and keep the BMW ones in the top box as a backup.
Like any kit choice there's no right and wrong - just what works for you...
Aaaaaaand another one for muffs. Put them on this morning for their 3rd season. Top kit even if they look a bit silly. But then that statement applies to the rider as well.