
Getting a new tyre fitted on Thursday (Anakee 3) , £120 all in,.......
Getting a new tyre fitted on Thursday (Anakee 3) , £120 all in,....... bloody £500 bill tomorrow for body repairs on the wife's car from x3 dinks ( none her fault , one hit and run and two f**k wits who ran into it when stopped), first service on the bmw next week which will no doubt be £160 and my car is in for a cam belt change next week as well . It never ends !!!!
A plugged tyre won't cause a blow out. Particularly the mushroom style plug, where the tyre pressure holds it in place along with friction.
A tubed tyre blowing out is a possibility though.
I had almost exactly the same thing happen to me at only a few hundred miles. I figured the same as the OP, replace the tyre. The construction is likely to be deformed by this sort of puncture and you wont necessarily be able to see the extent of the damage.
We pay all this money for a bike, why stick in a 2p mushroom repair which isn't rated to the same speed as the tyre (or any speed most likely) and risk damage to your new bike or worse, yourself....? To me it's madness for what these tyres cost compared to the bikes themselves.