I find it really hard to make comparisons between tyres, because a change in brand usually coincides with a change from old and squared off to new. After a knackered squared off tyre, anything vaguley corcularin profile is going to feel great.
The only tyres I have ever had real problems with were the Bridgestone Trailwings which came as OE on my 1150. They were hopeless in the wet.
Since then I've had Tourances (a few sets), Trailmax (OE on 1200), BT020 (on 1150) and Battlewings (current on 1200). I do really like current ones, though I can't really explain why. They seem quite neutral and grip as well as anything else I've had. I read somehwere that they were same construction and compound at BT020, so I think I'll stick with them for my next set (due soon).