Car or GS?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ScubaQuiche
  • Start date Start date

ScubaQuiche

Guest
Hello, I'm after some advice from the guys who ride all year through all winds and horrible weather. I sold my much loved CBR 2 months ago as it wasn't getting used but now I'm missing the biking experience. My wife and I have a car each, however I only use mine for work so its pretty much £7k of car sat doing nothing most of the time. Im thinking of getting rid and getting a used GS, I'm just wondering how it is riding in winter? Coming from a sports bike background I've only ridden on nice days. I work shifts and my commute is about 30 miles round trip. I really miss being on the bike and hate sitting in traffic in a sweat box!! Also it would have to permanently live outside. Any advice would be very much appreciated. Thanks SQ.
 
Sell the 7k car, buy an 1150 GS/A and with the change get a cheap and cheerful runabout car! :nenau













I have an Escort convertible for sale for £1495 ono! :D
 
nope,

sell your car

buy a used 650 dakar, it will do everything you want, and excite you on sunny days, and take you and the missis where ever.
the 1100/1150 are a lump of a bike if all your doing is commuting.
now dont get me wrong, they will do this day in day out, just
dont get suckered into the adventure thing,

go your own way

and also get a cheap van:thumb2
 
Its cold, wet and miserable in winter. Still don't go in the car/train.
 
i commuted on a Bike for 7 years.... 365...... what got to me in the end was not the wet/cold but the 15 min faff to dress up.......boots on, overtrousers, jackets, scarfs gloves..... and on a wet day i had no where at work to dry kit so come home time it was all about struggling into wet kit........ i bought a cheap car!..... there are guys on here who think nothing on paying £800-£1000 on rukka/gortex/twatsuits..... i sold Spanner of this parish a £250 Peugeot 305 with a years MOT.......thats three years motoring from one goretex suit!

£7k gets you a £2k car for commuting and a £5k bike .......
 
The only times you can't really ride bike are in snow and Ice, now that is really only for a few weeks of the year, the rest of the time it's the only way to travel.

Out of you 7K you could spend a couple of hundred quid on things like Muffs and heated waistcoat, not really necessary, but they do make it much more pleasurable, and you can use them when not going to work. Same goes for Autocom/starcom etc so you can listen to your favourite tunes whilst effortlessly passing commuters sitting in the long queues :D

You know it makes sense, regardless which bike you choose :thumb2
 
I only passed my car test two years ago, so used to ride all year round using a decent bike 8 months/year and a hack over the winter.

As I only have a short commute it's definitely easier in the car in winter and a lot more pleasant too thanks to the aircon, heated seats, traction control, ABS, heated windscreen etc. :augie

Personally I'd buy a £5k bike and £2k car and have the best of both worlds :thumb2
 
Definately have a cheap car so you do have the choice ;)

I got a 95 N Clio off a tosser on here nearly 2 years ago, and now its got 24000 miles on it.... ;)

£500 for two years commuting, and its still worth £500 any time of the day :thumb

My problem is that it would take me longer to kit up and get the bike out, than it would to jump in the car and drive to work.....
 
Hmm, a definite theme forming here:)

You have told us that you have a 30 mile commute but no other detail.

If I'm guessing correctly that it's 30 miles each way and that a lot of that is in traffic then the suiting up will be more than compensated by the ability to filter past stationary traffic.

You do need good riding gear which can cost lots as you'll know. If drying space in your place of work is at a premium then Goretex Pro-Shell or similar is the way to go as the laminated outer fabric/membrane doesn't soak up water resulting in a mini Niagra when you walk into work. I currently use a Vanucci one piece suit, laminated, armoured and quick to put on/remove. It will go over office clothes so unzip and your ready for work. About £370.00 from GetGeared on the web or Louis.de which was cheaper when I bought mine. +1 on the muffs, I use a set with perforated summer gloves through the winter, in fact they are still on now:augie

As for the bike will it only be your commuter or will it be your only bike? If it's your only bike then an 1150GS would be a good all rounder for less than the value of your car. Should be reliable as well. I personally wouldn't bother about the Adventure but then I like to get both feet flat on the ground to give a margin for the times when there are potholes or uneven road surfaces, cambers etc. If you're filtering you can't always choose your stopping point and car drivers may take a dim view of you falling on their "pride and joy":D. You'll also probably need a bit of luggage capacity as inevitably there are things that you need to carry at least some times. If cases are narrower than the bars they don't interfere with filtering much but the GS's are big wide bikes. You won't slither through wafer thin gaps that a smaller, narrower bike would.

If it's only to commute I'd probably buy a scoot. Some of them handle well, have more than enough performance, better weather protection and will use less fuel which is going to be of increasing priority as costs inevitably rise. I'd guess that you may get as little as 30mpg from a GS in a slow, stop and start commute. Scoots also have underseat luggage space. I don't know what the running costs are but the Yam T-Max is a serously fast scoot and I'd consider the auto transmission a benefit in traffic.

Riding in snow or on ice to me is bloody scary. I have been caught out a few times over the last couple of winters and was glad of a back-up car on the worst days.

Good luck whatever way you choose to go, keep us posted.
 
Just a thought

Save £35 quid for a bike safe course. There are a lot of idiots out there. You will meet several every day. It pays to be well prepared.

I do use my GS in central London all year. Frost and snow hardly a problem. The bike is surprizingly good in traffic. :thumb2

Ride safe:thumb

Path.
 
I sold my Fireblade and crappy old van to get my Gs:D
The money was ment to be spent on a nice shiny van:blast
But shit happens and I now cart my work kit around in a £400.oo worth of Proton it Stops,goes and hasn't broken down yet:)

Wouldn't have it any other way, Ok may be I'd have a new Van aswell if I had the spare $ at the mo.

The whole commuting thing is better by bike Chiswick to WC2 for 6 years on a mix of YZF750R Sp and KLR600 (although it was possibly quicker on the KLR:eek:)

£6K Bike
£500 car
£500 on new kit

Cheers Duncan
 
Get muffs, decent overgear and a heated jacket, that'll take care of most weather's. For the winter, buy a tatty old car with 6 months tax and mot and use that for the really bad weather.

I ride my gs most days to work year round. Snow buggered it up a bit this year, and this week I'm on the tube because I'm filming at Kings Cross so it makes more sense.
 
Bikes are great for commuting, if the distance justifies it. My clinic is only 2 miles down the road so it's not even worth kitting up. But I also work at a clinic in Sheffield which is about a 40 mile round trip of heavy traffic. It's much easier, and more fun on my GSA.

There are times though when a bike won't do. Snow and ice for one, unless you have a death wish. Or when you have lots and lots of stuff to carry with you.

As stated above I think you still need a car as well :thumb2
 
Get muffs, decent overgear and a heated jacket, that'll take care of most weather's. For the winter, buy a tatty old car with 6 months tax and mot and use that for the really bad weather.

I ride my gs most days to work year round. Snow buggered it up a bit this year, and this week I'm on the tube because I'm filming at Kings Cross so it makes more sense.

There are only crack heads and hoe's at Kings Cross what you filming:confused:
 
I too am a shift worker 24/7, I ride to work even in the middle of winter, when it drops down to 10 deg c at night, it gets a bit chilly in shorts, but I have learned to put up with it, it only lasts for a couple of months.
Buy yourself a bike, you can always pinch the wifes car when the weather gets bad.
 
I too am a shift worker 24/7, I ride to work even in the middle of winter, when it drops down to 10 deg c at night, it gets a bit chilly in shorts, but I have learned to put up with it, it only lasts for a couple of months.
Buy yourself a bike, you can always pinch the wifes car when the weather gets bad.

10 deg C, that's like summer over here :JB
 


Back
Top Bottom