Dilema! Keep 1150GSA or buy 1200GSA???

crazywakey

Madhouse Stuntman.
UKGSer Subscriber
Joined
Sep 16, 2006
Messages
176
Reaction score
2
Location
Dunstable, Beds. (Broken England)
My bike is 10 years old this year, has almost 41k miles on the clock, 33k of which are mine. Its taken me around the UK, over to Germany, and all the way to Italy and Slovenia in the time I've owned it. It's had only one niggle (that being a lightly leaking seal in the final drive unit, which I've had replaced twice) but apart from that, it's been a true warrior, through 2 winters and 3 summers. In short, I've loved owning it.

I'm about to get a promotion at work, so with the increase in wonga, I thought about upgrading to an 11 plate 1200GSA from my local dealership. So I took it for a test ride last Saturday, and made some observations....

Naturally it's lighter, more modern, comes with bells and whistles such as adjustable suspension and ABS (mine is non ABS). And of course doesn't come with winter salt scars on the forks and engine (mine does :mad:) And something I would like to do to my own GSA is make the throttle lighter instead of Massey Ferguson heavy!!!

So when I got back to the dealership, and jumped on mine to go home, I was fully expecting it to feel slightly alien and old/outdated, especially with acceleration pickup. But here's the thing: I didn't feel a massive difference! My GSA has the Y-Piece in place of the Cat, which of course really makes a difference from standard.....so the pickup on mine really didn't feel much worse than the 1200.

And despite the newer bike being quite big, it still felt a slightly "lesser" bike than my 1150GSA, the "road presence" was better on mine.

And then there's the money side of things....the 1200 was sitting at £11500....without panniers or top box. So all things considered.....would it be worth swapping my bike for the 1200? If I'm lusting for the latest technology, that would have a sway in things, but the bond I have with my own bike is more than that.

My point to this thread (sorry it took so long to get here!) is has anyone else suffered the same indecision, and what was their own experiences and outcomes? I have a feeling a will keep mine, unless someone else can persuade me with a good argument!!!

:nenau
 
from what you say, doesn't really sound like much of a hard choice to me.

keep wot you got ands the money :)
 
I changed the throttle cables (3) on my 02' 1150GS, made a big difference to the Massey-Ferguson throttle. Oiling or spraying anything in the cables is useless.
 
Some 1200 owner or other will be along in a moment to accuse you of being a Troll for posting this in the 1200 section. :rolleyes:

My advice is this, they are both good bikes in their own ways but quite a lot different despite the shared genes. Unless the 1200 grabbed you and you are now visualising owning one, stick with what you have.

Oh and definitely worth swapping the cables (if it hasn't been done).
 
Sounds like you prefer your 1150 not sure what your hoping to get out of this thread only you can decide
 
Posted about he same before I got rid of the 1150 and bought a brand new R1200GSA, still prefer the 1150 !!!
 
So you need to give them about £7,000 plus your bike for something newer, slightly faster, slightly smoother but which you perceive to be little different.

With love and care your 1150 will do another 100,000 miles plus. The corrosion is easy to deal with for a few quid.

My cheque book would be staying firmly closed!
 
What's the indecision about? You've said you prefer your 1150, and this will save you several grand :confused:

Why not wait for the 1250 and try that instead?
 
My 2p's worth......My 2005 12GS was a great bike and I'd never had parted with it for a new one as I'd sorted it fully. It's just that some twat helped me total it. So, moral of the story is if you're happy with what you have keep it and cherish it. Throw a few pound at it you want to spend some cash but it's a big outlay to get something new and shiney which doesn't do too much more.
Cheers
 
They are both really good bikes with each having their own strengths and weaknesses but the 1150 has better build quality.
The main reason to change is age not mileage so if you decide to go for a 1200 then shop around the dealers for the bike and deal you want, (make sure you get the luggage). The dealers will be quiet until March and the new liquid cooled is out next year and sales are prices should reflect this.

If you use it in winter use copious amounts of ACF50
 
Had a 2x 1200 and went back to my 1150GSA........best decision I ever made! Buy a 660 Tenere or a 650gs to play with instead and keep the 1150
 
C'mon grampa and get with the times.......!

You've got a comfy old pair of slippers that smell of wee and the 'tartans' like well faded and frayed but you've tasted the coolaid good and think it's time for that new pair of Nike trainers.....!

You'd be da man then and a big hit with all da local Biatches and Ho's Bro.....!:bow

My missus said she saw my old 1150GSA the other day all 'grimed up' in the local ALDI carpark and although it still looked good she said it looked kinda............Small:blast

I still miss the old girl though....................................That'll teach her 'never' to 'dis' one of my old bikes again that's for sure!!!!!

Stick with the 1150.....You know it makes sense!

FP.:thumb
 
I've had both.....keep the 1150gsa and buy a big katoom.........:D

Me too (well not the Katoom bit)

I had a 12GSA, sold it and kept my 1150GSA - I concur with everything you said in Post #1

12GSA you either love them or....................

Same with a 1150GSA, there's them that do and them that don't
 
If you are happy with the 1150 and can't tell the difference, stick with the old girl.

When I ride an 1150 it seems slow and ponderous compared with my 1200 but if I had to have another 1150 for any reason, it wouldn't bother me at all.

Both cracking bikes:thumb
 
Go with what your heart tells you to do, not your head is all I can say.
Bit like the Dalai Lama going into a pizza shop and asking
"Can you make me one with everything?"
 


Back
Top Bottom