Jimmy Lewis: A street Bike in dirt Bike clothing

F650Dakar_Norway

Registered user
Joined
Aug 21, 2008
Messages
112
Reaction score
0
Location
Norway
http://www.dirtrider.com/reviews/motocross/141_0811_2009_bmw_f800gs_web_impression/index.html

Quote:
"Onto the off-road and here is where I see the biggest problem or shortcoming with the package. People might be buying this bike based on the impression that this is a big dirt bike. Forget it. This is a street bike that you can ride off-road. Or an adventure bike, one capable of going off-road, with caution. If you want a really big dirt bike get an HP2 or a KTM 950SE, there is a really big difference, trust me.

Typical to the GS line, this bike is not an Adventure version either. What I mean by that is the suspension is set up for street riding with a much less progressive damping and it rides low in the stroke. As such, it bottoms out at the first sight of a bump with a clank that is telling you, in mechanical language, that you are going to break something or crash and get hurt unless you slow down. Yes, we saw it happen a few times on our trip. From blown rear shocks to bent rims to broken bodies, we saw carnage. And yes, it was caused by 100% rider error in my not-so-humble opinion. I rode all the same places, usually slower than the affected parties and I was fine, so was my identical bike.

The riding position on the F800GS was comfortable from sit-down roads to technical stand-up off-road riding.The suspension is pretty much non-adjustable in the front. It rides too low in the stroke and could use some stiffer springs to use the top of the stroke more effectively. The rear has preload adjustment (I ran mine full stiff to get the most shock stroke I could) and there is an adjuster on the bottom of the shock that controls rebound, I assume, that I didn't feel the need to touch.

In the dirt the light feeling stays, which is a good thing if you don't get fooled into riding to fast! The handling is planted and the weight keeps the bike stuck to the ground and it gets good traction-as long as you possess and utilize throttle control. Because here the parallel twin gets very snappy and has a hit on the bottom of the power delivery that likes to light up the tire and get the bike moving too fast. I found it a lot better to be a gear or two high and really let the bike bog down to a smoother power level combined with enough clutch work to keep my speeds down.
"


My impressions exactly. The snappy throttle and non-adjustable suspension being the primary culprits IMHO. :beerjug:
 
Snappy?! A KTM 525/530 EXC is good for snappy and that's a dedicated off road machine. I get the feeling that often it's a case of many riders being street bikers at heart and
posing as enduro enthusiasts rather than the bikes being in disguise. Having said that though I agree that the f800GS is a tourer with moderate off road ability rather than a tool for David Knight.:hide
 
he is right of course but is wide of the mark in other areas... namely the seat.

I quote "The seat is really good and is helping the package" :rolleyes:

just goes to show. Opinions are like arseholes. Everyone's got one.
 
I'd say he's being a Master Of The Bloody Obvious.

Hardly a eye opener.

What next?
Saucepans are a bit awkward for frying eggs in? Freelanders don't cope as well as dedicated Dakar Rally 4x4's in offroad races? FFS.
 
he is right of course but is wide of the mark in other areas... namely the seat.

I quote "The seat is really good and is helping the package" :rolleyes:

just goes to show. Opinions are like arseholes. Everyone's got one.

I test rode an 800GS last spring and hated the hard seat, but took one out again in November and it was totally different. I don't know if BMW have changed the seat filling without advertising it, but I've no doubt the 2 seats I rode on were different. As a result I bought one, and am riding plenty of miles on it without any discomfort.

My 2p.
 
I'd say he's being a Master Of The Bloody Obvious.

Hardly a eye opener.

What next?
Saucepans are a bit awkward for frying eggs in? Freelanders don't cope as well as dedicated Dakar Rally 4x4's in offroad races? FFS.
:clap
There is a member of the gsers forums who rides an XR400 to morroco for off roading, will the next post be telling him it's not as fast as an 1150gs through Spain!!
As the old saying goes "he has a degree in stating the bleeding obvious"!!
 
I test rode an 800GS last spring and hated the hard seat, but took one out again in November and it was totally different. I don't know if BMW have changed the seat filling without advertising it, but I've no doubt the 2 seats I rode on were different. As a result I bought one, and am riding plenty of miles on it without any discomfort.

My 2p.

I have the lowered seat and it is good up to about 150 miles. After that it is a pain in the arse. I use an airhawk after that and I'm good for 1000 miles :thumb
 
I have the lowered seat and it is good up to about 150 miles. After that it is a pain in the arse. I use an airhawk after that and I'm good for 1000 miles :thumb

And I have the higher, more narrow OEM BMW enduro seat and it's good for hundreds of miles sans butt aches. It also allows my recently torn ligament-operated left knee a better angle and improves my personal rider comfort.

The too snappy throttle is still a problem for mye personal prefs when gravel-roading and riding technical, so I'll either hacksaw-modify the throttle cam on the handlebar or get a G2 throttle tamer to avoid the "bucking bronco" caused by the IMHO too fast initial throttle response when riding standing in the footpegs over demanding bumps/terrain: http://www.advrider.com/forums/showthread.php?t=471840&highlight="f800GS+throttle" :augie
 


Back
Top Bottom