New R1250RS “Pinking” noise

FYI, a modern GS can recognise if it's "pinking". The crank sensor can pick up pre-detonation events from inaccuracies in the wave-form. And it would pull up an engine management light.
 
I started this thread last year and thought I would give a final update. I have had the bike out a lot in the last month and enjoying exploring its performance. The noise is still there but I am convinced it is a fluttering of the butterfly vale / valves on the intake. It happens in any gear about 2 cm of throttle on and then clears with more throttle. I had seen this referenced in other postings and even some solutions about rotating the throttle body but I don't want to start tinkering. I am just leaving it as it is and enjoying the bike.
 
I started this thread last year and thought I would give a final update. I have had the bike out a lot in the last month and enjoying exploring its performance. The noise is still there but I am convinced it is a fluttering of the butterfly vale / valves on the intake. It happens in any gear about 2 cm of throttle on and then clears with more throttle. I had seen this referenced in other postings and even some solutions about rotating the throttle body but I don't want to start tinkering. I am just leaving it as it is and enjoying the bike.
I found you could avoid the noise by riding gentler (but still achieving high speeds) but I didn’t want to be restricted by a fault. My engine replacement under warranty has been flawless and it is smooth as butter.
 
It deffo seems to be related to the quality/grade/brand of petrol.
I`ve just done a ~500 mile mini-tour of Wales on the GSA, when i set off i filled up with Shell V-power E5.
The bike was quiet and ran normally.
Out in the wilds of rural Wales i had to fill up from a local `Oil4Wales` garage with regular E10.
The bike started pinking under certain riding conditions almost straight away....

I reckon the bikes are tuned right on the borderline of pinking to make the Euro regs and emmision targets etc and any fuel you use which strays from the ideal will tip them into detonation territory.
Lets just hope there isn`t any potential for lasting damage because of this..
 
On the way back from Devon today along the A303.
Two-up with luggage so fairly well loaded, cruising at just under 70, as soon as one of those long uphill gradients came up and i had to increase the throttle a bit to keep momentum up the engine could be heard to pink like mad. I do not like the engine making that noise for any length of time...

However, snap the throttle open further to accelerate slightly so that the Shiftcam operates and the hi lift cams engage the pinking instantly stops.
 
Hi, sorry for the late post. I just had my R1250GS engine replaced due to this noise. I took it to BMW and said if you can't diagnose it then it's not safe to ride, I won't accept 'we don't know what it is'. I suggest you push on this! Also, put a camera/gopro on your bike to record the noise, it's MUCH easier to get it sorted if you can provide evidence.

Here is the sound my bike made, is this similar to yours? Low RPM acceleration in any gear and 70mph on the motorway.
Rattle sound video 1
Rattle sound video 2
Hi there!
I think I have a similar issue, could you please repost your videos? They seem to have been turned down. Thanks!
 
I'm late to the party. The R1250 engines have a knock sensor. The R1200 LC doesn't. My R1200R sounds like it's pinking at lower RPM but if I open the throttle harder it goes.
 
thnik i amy have mentioned this before when i had my 1250 after a while notiving a slight tinkering noise at around 3to 4500 revs i eventually put it down to slight vibes / rattles from the fairings sending the sound up through the top , i maybe wrong !!!!
 
Quick update: I had the bike checked by BMW dealer again. They were able to reproduce the noise and told me it is coming from the intake system and throttle body components, not from the engine itself, and that they consider it normal.

I’m still trying to get an official answer from BMW regarding the engine oil used during my 20,000 km service though. The bike was filled with BMW ADVANTEC Pro 15W-50, while the owner’s manual specifies 5W-40, so I’ve asked BMW to confirm whether 15W-50 is officially approved for this model, and if that can be causing the noise.
 
Quick update: I had the bike checked by BMW dealer again. They were able to reproduce the noise and told me it is coming from the intake system and throttle body components, not from the engine itself, and that they consider it normal.

I’m still trying to get an official answer from BMW regarding the engine oil used during my 20,000 km service though. The bike was filled with BMW ADVANTEC Pro 15W-50, while the owner’s manual specifies 5W-40, so I’ve asked BMW to confirm whether 15W-50 is officially approved for this model, and if that can be causing the noise.
Who filled it with 15/50 ?

And how do you know ?

Countless people run 15/50 in these with no issues. If anything, it would make the engine quieter.

It's obviously not the correct oil (if you ask BMW), but that's doesn't mean anything. You won't get an an answer from an engineer. Just someone reading from a document they don't really understand.
 
Last edited:
Who filled it with 15/50 ?

And how do you know ?

Countless people run 15/50 in these with no issues. If anything, it would make the engine quieter.

It's obviously not the correct oil (if you ask BMW), but that's doesn't mean anything. You won't get an an answer from an engineer. Just someone reading from a document they don't really understand.
One of the official BMW dealerships in my city filled it, they specified it in my invoice. When I asked, they told me that their AIR system is presumably showing 15/50 as an acceptable alternative, and refused to change it to 5/40... I asked BMW for confirmation, but they are ignoring me for several months...(
 
I'm particularly concerned right now because in my place it's around 0°C, and I'm still riding. This incorrect oil has higher viscosity as far as I understand, my concern is that it can damage something during the cold starts...
 
One of the official BMW dealerships in my city filled it, they specified it in my invoice. When I asked, they told me that their AIR system is presumably showing 15/50 as an acceptable alternative, and refused to change it to 5/40... I asked BMW for confirmation, but they are ignoring me for several months...(
Nowhere in Air does it say that.. I have AIR. Your dealer is a real arsehole.

Still, I don't think it would do any harm whatsoever.

A quick Google shows 15w50 is fine down to minus 20. But Minus 12 being a preferable low temperature.
 
give enough zloty to BMW and you can rent it ...
Just become a professional Motorcycle workshop, prove your technical credentials (I have been to the BMW academy many times and have my accreditations) and then apply to BMW to join their network. Once approved you are are able to plug into the Mothership and have access to all of the same software and systems as a big fancy main dealer.

And you are correct. It is certainly not free. If I want to check AIR (Manuals, service information, recall info, technical bulletins etc), it costs me £9 per hour. Yes. PER HOUR...

I'm not allowed to sell or share the information. Nor would I.
 
You pay the dealer, the dealer pays the mothership .. all the money flows upwards .. a bit like an organised crime group, or the Church of England. A well proven business model.
 
back to pinking. My 1200RS pinked, as did my GSA. It happened under load, more so with the extra heft of the GSA in low revs, pulling away particularly. I don't think it had anything to do wit the flapper valve and when service time came, my local dealer told me unequivocally that ALL 1200's had anti knock sensors (which were not restricted to 1250 models). My 1250 RT did too but less so. I stripped my exhaust, cleaned and checked my flapper valve assembly and found no play that could account for this nor could I replicate the noise in neutral, testing the flapper valve position with revs. I am convinced, despite all the protestations from BMW that it was pinking, as it was worse when using standard petrol instead of E5. I ignored it in the end and learned not to labour the bikes but to keep them above 2.5 K revs when riding.
 


Back
Top Bottom