After 4,400 miles in 11 months, I’ve just traded in my Crosstourer for a new liquid cooled GS.
Up until 4 years ago, I had been “Honda Man” for a long time and put many tens of thousands of miles on Hondas generally and well over 60,000 miles on my Honda VFR800FiY. Following a knee injury, I moved to a GS, and absolutely loved the more relaxed riding position and general feel of the bike. I did well over 20,000 trouble free miles in 3 years and enjoyed the bike tremendously, so when the Crosstourer appeared, I was delighted to see that Honda had a bike which seemed to really challenge the GS at last. That 1200 V4 was so much nicer than the old single cam boxer!
My recent trip to the Isle of Man TT gave me an opportunity to really think about the Crosstourer, since I was riding it every day and the trip included the motorway miles to the port, several laps of the famous circuit as well horribly congested Douglas roads and the IOM’s beautiful back lanes. I still think that V4 is a brilliant engine, and it’s smoother than the new liquid cooled BMW twin, for sure. But, there are three things about the Crosstourer which I am less keen on (in order of dislike):
• The wind protection – and everyone I’ve talked to agrees that it’s less than good! Despite trying the standard, Honda touring and Givi screens, I have still to find something which is comfortable on fast A roads and motorways. Put it simply, my head’s getting bashed about and it’s too noisy, even at 70. Long distances on this bike are no fun, and that almost certainly explains why it’s done just 4,500 miles whereas I’d expect to do more like 7,500 in a year. Thinking about it, I can recall several occasions when I’ve taken the train or car in preference to the Crosstourer.
• The jerky throttle response and general backlash in the transmission. This hasn’t been the subject of much debate on here, but I find it almost impossible to ride it smoothly at low speeds and at times the crashing and banging from the transmission has had me quite worried – running into a village with the throttle closed in, say, 4th, really does sound horrible. So horrible that my bike’s been back to the dealer twice and each time I’ve been told that all is well. This is the DCT owners’ cue to tell me I bought the wrong transmission!
• The front suspension isn’t a patch on the BMW system. On the mountain, I felt that the front of the bike really wasn’t very well controlled under heavy braking from (legal!) three figure speeds.
So, today I went and rode a BMW R1200GS TE and it’s a different bike to the old one. Wind protection up to 90 is fine (the screen is adjustable on the move and the new bike even has a built in version of winglets), the engine is very similar but very different to the old boxer and the selectable throttle modes mean you can bimble or fly at will. I really rather like it and mine arrives on June 29th.
So, maybe I’m not Honda Man after all…..