He had taken out single trip cover for a duration of 2 weeks and we were still within that period.
OK, that’s a fresh bit of news. I have had a very brief skim through the Nationwide policy, searching it for the word ‘return’. The policy blurb seems to vary between ‘booked’ return and ‘planned’ return. Leaving aside that variations are possibly not a good thing, it is easy to assume that:
A. Booked, means a date / time of crossing has been arranged, paid for and a ticket issued.
B. Planned can mean a bunch of things. For example, “I plan on returning before the two week duration of the policy period is up” or, “I plan to come home, on the date and time of my booked crossing”. Both are plans, of a sort.
In part at least, the policy blurb needs a return date, as some covers cease as soon as the date is passed.
Note:
A. We have no way of knowing what policy your friend bought from Nationwide, nor its wording.
B. Nationwide seem to rely on the AA (or their overseas partners) for vehicle assistance. I guess it was the AA (not Nationwide) who told your friend that no return booking equals no cover?
C. I only gave the policy a very brief look.
I would tell your friend to complain, now that he’s back. If nothing else, Nationwide or the AA will have to address the complaint in writing. If he’s still not happy, he can then complain further and further up the tree.
Note:
I see that the Nationwide policy excludes looking after any pets in the vehicle, which remain the responsibility of the owner to cart about. Those who travel with two or more large dogs, might well be scuppered when the hire car turns out to be a VW Up or smaller.
Those who don’t plan anything, winging their return crossing, might like to read their policies for breakdown and travel insurance.