Warped Discs prevention and checks.

  • Thread starter Thread starter The Mechanic
  • Start date Start date

The Mechanic

Guest
Having read quite a few of your posts concerning 'warped discs' etc. I thought that some useful and reasonably easy to carry out checks would be useful to anyone eho is fairly DIY mechanically competent.

You will need plenty of light, a measurement device such as a steel ruler, vernier caliper, dial test indicator; these last two offer the ability to be far more accurate in any readings/measurements obtained.

Bike should be on the main stand, paddock stand or blocks so that either the front wheel or rear are clear of the ground.

Squeeze the front brake lever a few times and operate the rear brake a few stabs as well, chack to see if the wheels rotate easily without too much binding. It is entirely normal for the pads to just rub slightly, when the bkie is moving centrifugal force and the brake caliper piston seal (returning to its normal shape....not under the influence of hydraulic pressure) will tend to pull/throw the pads away very slightly from the disc. Thats the reason why it is so important to keep the pistons and seals clean.

Now you are familiar with the general feel of the brakes as they are at present you can proceed to the next stage.

Decide which end you want to do first, prepare the machine so that the wheel you have chosen is a couple of inches clear of the ground. Rotate the wheel by hand and just observe the rim and tyre to make sure they are not ovalised, wobbling or doing anything they shouldn't be.

Now if you are working on the front wedge some rag into the brake lever so that you or someone alse does not inadvertently operate it, alternatively put something under the rear brake pedal or on top to prevent same.

Remove (for the front wheel) both sets of pads keep them in order so that they are fitted back into the same position in the caliper (same side of the disc). The rear brake will be attended to in the same manner but obviously only one set of pads will be removed.

Again with rotate the wheel by hand, it should spin considerably more easily than before giving consideration to speedo drive, oil seal friction, and for the rear a degree of added friction due to the transmisssion.

We are now concentrating our attention around the disc and brake caliper region. Observe the gap either side of the brake caliper whilst rotating the wheel, note any wobble if it appears to you observable to the naked eye in the disc....this is serious.

Take hold of the wheel top and bottom and (preferably with someone staedying the bike test the wheel bearings for sideways movement....there should be NO discernable movement. Do this for both wheels when convenient.

If all is ok, we will now start to carry out measurements.

Take your chosen measuring device and carefully measure the distance between the brake disc and a fixed reference point on the brake caliper body ( I would suggest the outer flat edge where the pad slides into the caliper as this is identical on both sides of the caliper). Now note down the measurement and then rotate the wheel through 1/4 revolution and measure again, repeat until you have at least four readings/measuerments.

Now repeat the operation on the opposite disc, noting down the readings.

Don't panic if you get wildly differing readings...calm down and double check the measurements again.

I do not have B*W's specifications for brake disc run-out, suffice it to say that there should be NO discernable difference between your readings at any stage.

WHAT TO DO IF YOU HAVE A SUSPECTED WARPED DISC:

Assuming the warranty has expired or you want to prove a point then follow the next steps.

Unbolt the brake disc from the wheel hub and make sure that the mounting area is free from burrs or raised (pulled) threads, what this means is that the hub/disc mating surface is totally smooth. You don't need to remove the whee to do this on the front.

Rotate the disc around one or two mounting holes and then refix using a torque wrench to finally tighten the mounting bolts. Do these bolts up evenly and work diagonally so that the disc can seat down evenly if you tighten the bolts like going round a clock face you will most certainly 'load' the disc.

Time for a cuppa....or something stronger!

Right, rested.....good, now for the next stage.

Measure each brake pad, they should all be the same in pad thickness. You may if you wish gently rub the braking surface of the pad with emery cloth placed over a perfectly flat surface, this will remove any bedding in marks and will affect your braking until the pad has bedded in again. The reason for this exercise is to enable you to make both pads give the same thickness measurement.

Apply a 'thin' coating of either Copa-Slip or high melting point grease, to the pad metal backing and the edges of the metal backing that contact the caliper. Refit the pads WITHOUT the retainers to BOTH sides and apply the brake lever a few times.

Slacken the caliper to fork leg mounting bolts ( one to two complete turns of the bolts) Now apply the brake again and you should still be able to move the caliper very slightly up and down as though trying to move the caliper in the same direction as the wheel. If this is not possible the caliper is out of alignment with the disc, you may need to add small shims between the caliper and fork leg mounting points or the caliper mounting faces may need to be reduced slightly. If this sounds complicated let me assure you it isn't and its something any professional thats worth their salt would do as a matter of course. You've come this far don't give up now!

Another area to check is the wheel spindle to wheel spacer clamping effect. In other words is the wheel spindle pulling the forks to far together and forcing the calipers out of true alignment with the brake discs.

Warning you cannot do this next bit on a bike with single sided (slider type calipers). With the brake calipers tightened to the fork mountings, slacken the wheel spindle and see if the wheel spins any freer than before. If it does then the wheel spindle is pulling the forks out of true aligment, creating binding brakes and uneven loading of the discs which will cause warping sooner than later.

The remedy is to fit slightly longer spacers or use a shim or two, on the other hand it is entirely possible for this scenario to be reversed and the fork/wheel spacers could be forcing the legs outward creating the same effect.

Try getting someone to hold the brake on whilst the wheel spindle is tightened and then see what effect that has.

Finally the brake calipers need to be serviced for cleansing. To do this remove the pad on one side of the caliper only, GENTLY apply the brake lever a SMALL amount and the piston will move in towards the disc. Thoroughly clean the exposed part of the piston and then smear either rubber grease or as I have used to great effect a small amount of 'o'-ring chain lube with a small paint brush. Ease the piston back in just sufficient to allow the brake pad to be reinserted. CARE wrap some rag around the master cylinder just in case you force the piton back too far, there shouldn't be any leakage from the reservoir, but just in case.

Now double check everything that you have disturbed, ensure the brake pad locating pins and security devices are fitted back correctly, all brake caliper bolts are correctly tightened and the wheel spindle (if disturbed) is tightened to the correct torque setting.

Now roll the bike back and forth working the brakes on and off to ensure they are SAFE. Go for a ride.......

Obviuosly I'm relying on your common sense here so if you still have a warped disc it will need to be sorted with B*W or your dealer etc.

Good luck in your quest, and if you do all of the above its entirely at your own risk, I accept no responsibility whatsoever. But you'll notice that your brakes are probably alot better than they were.

WARNING WARNING if you have ABS brakes please be very careful not to damage the SENSOR / PICK-UP or its wire.

Good luck, this took me longer to type out than it did to actually do the work explained.

:)
 
Bloody hell, I haven't read all that, but if your discs warp coming down a pass in the pyrenees like a hooligan, you still end up with knackered discs. right:confused:
 
Hooligan?

Vern said:
Bloody hell, I haven't read all that, but if your discs warp coming down a pass in the pyrenees like a hooligan, you still end up with knackered discs. right:confused:

Don't think B*W would agree, brakes are brakes and shouldn't warp the first time you have to use them for their intended purpose ie slowing down,stopping or knocking off speed suddenly.

Warped discs are down to two things usually, piss poor quality materials such as unstable metal ( foundary problem) inadequate specification materials......oh and incorrect fitting procedures.

B*W don't use floating dicss unlike the majority of Jap manufacturers so some of the fault could stem from the design.

Cue thousands of GSer's who have never had warped discs, they probably brake earlier and therefore do not create excess heat in the discs. If the brakes are held on at astandstill whilst the discs are very hot then some warpage might occur.

I'm sure your not confused Vern after all you work with metals and must surely understand the propoerties. If the discs were thicker then warpage might be such a pronounced GS (and other models) problem, alternatively if they were floating discs there may never have been a problem to start with.

Did you read all of that?:) ;)
 
Clearly put Mechanic............thanks for brushing up on the details...:thumb

CC

:cool:
 
My first set of discs went after 127k (worn out not warped) 2nd set lasted 3k and warped, third set now done 20k and still ok. All three sets were of the floating kind, just like everyone elses.:D
 
Non-floating.....

Vern said:
My first set of discs went after 127k (worn out not warped) 2nd set lasted 3k and warped, third set now done 20k and still ok. All three sets were of the floating kind, just like everyone elses.:D

1150 GS discs are bolted directly to the hub and don't float so they can be more prone to warping in certain circumstances.

:)
 
i changed the rusty crap looking disc holding bolts on my 1100 front wheel discs. Once i'd wound them out from the loctite, they absolutely definitely had a spring washer behind the head to enable them to float.

replaced with st st 316 m8 button heads - and loctite about 6 months ago before anyone says - ' they're no good etc etc'

Anyway - as far as i can tell the 1150 brakes look exactly the same - but i'm only looking at web pics .

i reckon the disc warping is due to patchy material quality and marginal disc design thickness. - thats why its so hit n miss.

How come some people get new discs warping (or not) when bolted back up to the same wheel ?

Phil
 
1150 GS discs are bolted directly to the hub and don't float so they can be more prone to warping in certain circumstances

1150 discs are definitely floating. Undo the bolts and you will find bobbins under them.

As an aside, its usually the alloy carrier on jap bikes which distorts and pulls the disc out of true. This is caused by one or more bobbins seizing and providing a heat-sink into the alloy which is not designed to resist this localised heating. The discs themselves are often OK.
 
Excellent advice thanks, I can't believe how helpful everyone is and how much good advice is available.

Thanks very much.

David
 
Here we go...

Jap discs sit on a rotor so the disc is free to loose it heat via the rotor and the atmosphere.
The 1150/1100 has no rotor so the disc only looses heat directly through the hub and the excuse for floating discs is lost, they just wobble which exsaserbates the problem when warpage occurs.

Motomartin has hit the nail on the head and it is some what borne out by verns 127k and then 3k before problems and then 20k+ without problems.

If you think its bad for warped discs in the bike trade, you will not believe the problems that cars have....but they tend to be dirt cheap replacement stuff...usually!:)
 
Re: Here we go...

The Mechanic said:
Jap discs sit on a rotor so the disc is free to loose it heat via the rotor and the atmosphere.
The 1150/1100 has no rotor

Sorry, mechanic - your off-track here.

BM's (Brembo) have EXACTLY the same arrangement as most japs, other than the carrier is part of the hub casting on BM's rather than being a separate alloy casting. The disc is floating, the same as japs (& Italian & British).

The basic idea is that the disc DOES NOT transfer too much heat into the alloy carrier and is isolated via the bobbins. The vast majority of the disc-heat is lost to the atmosphere.

Early disc-brake designs had a solidly-mounted disc to the hub. This created warpage problems in high-stress conditions (e.g. racing, heavily-loaded touring) because of the uneven thermal-links between the extremely hot disc and the hub. The way around this was to isolate the disc from the hub as far as possible via bobbins. This allowed the disc to become very hot, but to shed most of its heat back to atmosphere rather than via the hub, carrier, whatever and ultimately, wheel-bearings. The final stage in this development was the introduction of sintered pads, which were (are) much better at working at the elevated temperatures demanded by this design.

Have a close look at your front wheel. :)
 
My bloody disks are causing front wheel judder on my bike. No doubt they are warped and I will need to spend money. Its all about expansion and contraction, and dislocations in the steel at a molecular level. Its also about £££££.
 
If you've come to a stop after using your brakes hard. Don't keep the brakes applied - let go of the lever .

Otherwise the heat will be contained in the area where the pads contact the disc = warped disc
 
My 2002 1150 GS Adventure (54K miles) failed its MOT today with what the fail certificate says it 'excessive fluctuation of brake effort' which he suggested might be warped discs.

So onto the forums and finds this excellent post.

I had a check and the disks look OK and rough measurement suggests no problem. So its onto cleaning the calipers and checking I haven't got the forks slightly out of true when I last replaced the front tyre.
 
Question about disc bolts

Slowly working my way through checking everything. This may be a dumb question but here goes. The discs are mounted to the hub by five bolts. With the bolts tightened to 24nm as recommended by the manual should I still be able to move the disc on the hub by hand? Not a lot of movement but it is noticeable.

Thanks Paul
 
stuyvpc said:
should I still be able to move the disc on the hub by hand? Not a lot of movement but it is noticeable.

Thanks Paul

Very common problem - do a search, i haven't the time to type it all out at the moment
 
Ahah

When I search for 'disc movement' instead of 'disk movement' it all becomes clear :confused:
 


Back
Top Bottom