Which GPS?

LPB

Active member
UKGSer Subscriber
Joined
Mar 22, 2004
Messages
202
Reaction score
9
Location
Dorset
I am considering buying a GPS.

Is the BMW Nav II worth the xtra cost overthe Garmin equivalent?

Lloyd.
 
I assume, reading netween the lines, that the answer is no.

I understand the 2610 to be the equivalent - can anyone confirm that please,
Thanks,

Lloyd.
 
Mike O said:
... lifetime mapping upgrades
Can you show me, in writing, where BMW says this ?

With the Navigator (original) some dealers made verbal promises of mapping upgrades which did not eventuate.
BMW claimed that the dealers had misunderstood their reps.

"A verbal contract is worth the paper it is written on"
 
BurnieM said:
Can you show me, in writing, where BMW says this ?

With the Navigator (original) some dealers made verbal promises of mapping upgrades which did not eventuate.
BMW claimed that the dealers had misunderstood their reps.

"A verbal contract is worth the paper it is written on"

So, your dealers lied to you too...........?

Cheers

Dutch
 
BurnieM said:
Can you show me, in writing, where BMW says this ?

With the Navigator (original) some dealers made verbal promises of mapping upgrades which did not eventuate.
BMW claimed that the dealers had misunderstood their reps.

"A verbal contract is worth the paper it is written on"

No Bernie, I can't. I was quoting from other peoples (apparently wrong) advice. TBH, it makes little difference to me, as I bought mine in the USA, with a recently released map version - by the time I'm due to upgrade my US maps, I'll be long gone... Still got my UK maps from my SPIII though...

Mike:)
 
Mike O said:
No Bernie, I can't. I was quoting from other peoples (apparently wrong) advice. TBH, it makes little difference to me, as I bought mine in the USA, with a recently released map version - by the time I'm due to upgrade my US maps, I'll be long gone... Still got my UK maps from my SPIII though...

Mike:)

When you are comparing 2 very similar models the devil is in the detail.

You need to understand the detail before you can determine whether the more expensive unit is worth the money.

Please don't quote second hand information as it creates ongoing confusion
 
BurnieM said:
When you are comparing 2 very similar models the devil is in the detail.

You need to understand the detail before you can determine whether the more expensive unit is worth the money.

Please don't quote second hand information as it creates ongoing confusion

Thanks for the advice, headmaster :rolleyes:

The point I was trying to make was that, unlike the Navigator, which was little more than a re-badging of a SPIII, the Navigator II has significant differences when compared with the 2610.

Mike:)
 
Mike O said:
Thanks for the advice, headmaster :rolleyes:

The point I was trying to make was that, unlike the Navigator, which was little more than a re-badging of a SPIII, the Navigator II has significant differences when compared with the 2610.

Mike:)
And map upgrades is NOT one of them

Sorry if I am short but there is a lot of confusion out there.
I work part time for a Garmin/Magellan dealer and I spend the first 10 minutes with a customer just getting rid of bad information.
From a sales viewpoint this does not help us either as sometimes the customer does not know who to believe.

I believe the differences are the Navigator II comes with a 4 button pad/battery pack that attaches to the left of the unit and a larger data card (in some markets).
Whether it is worth buying the BMW version depends on the cost.
My viewpint is that if it is 150-220 euro more than the Garmin then it is probably worth it.
(I believe the SP2610 will not work with the button pad (firmware mod) so you cannot just buy a BMW pad)

Note if you have an existing SPIII that the Garmin SP2610 motorcycle cradle comes with the standard 4 hole pattern and will attach straight to a BMW or Garmin or RAM base. All you need to do is wire in the power cable (bare ends).

A Garmin SP2610 in Australia is AU$1820 and comes with;
GPSR
beanbag dash mount
permanent dash mount
cig lighter power/speaker cable
remote control
128MB CF card (preloaded with CNA)
City Navigator Australia v5 CD
USB cable
Mains power adapter


PS just for the record the SP2610 and Navigator II (just like the SPIII and Navigator) are equally petrol resistant (or not)
 


Back
Top Bottom