I'd give it a try. Router performance is very much a factor of a) the way you use it and b) your physical environment. You will only see reviews from people who had trouble not the 95% of customers who have no problems, much like motorcycle reliability.
Although, saying that, I do prefer ISPs like Airband who give you a decent branded router rather than a bespoke item. The former is more likely to have a pretty generic interface if you need to modify the settings and the geeky forums more likely to have help pages of you do encounter a problem with a particular accessory, VPN etc.