I've had mine for around a year.... they are very comfy, warm too,
they make your feet a bit pungent when you've had them on all day in hot weather, there is the buckle issue, which I easily fixed with some of those tiny dots of velcro in appropriate places, your feet do get wet, however in p*ssing rain conditions I found with my oversuit trousers as far down over the ankle bit as possible my feet stayed dry all day... would I buy another pair? possibly
although I may be tempted by a pair of alpinestar tech 8's next time....................