Same problem... i think?????
I've just come across this thread with interest... my -05 GS is ALWAYS plugged into my Optimate 3 as soon as it's placed back in the garage after EVERY ride.... the optimate connects direct to the battery (using the connector that came with the optimate)
Whenever i go to the bike, the optimate shows fully charged, no problems... although when i return from a ride, even long rides, and plug the battery back to the optimate, it normally takes over 8hrs to get back to fully charged state?
I've never seen this as a problem, as the battery is always tip top by the time i next use it. HOWEVER... a couple of weeks ago, i went to my bike (it having not been used for around 4-6 weeks) disconnected it from the optimate (indicating fully charged) and took it for an 80 mile ride to work. Finished my days work, went back to the bike, turned the ignition and was met by speedo cluster lights coming on, almost immediately turning off again and complete ignition failure???
I tried the normal, ignition off, ignition back on... but now with the ignition on, there was absolutely zero power, it had completely died. The bike was in exactly the same state with the ignition on or off....
I called BMW Assistance.... 1 hour later, still had not had a callback with ETA... so figured the only thing i could think of doing, was disconnecting the battery, to force the bikes electrical circuits to reset... I disconnected, reconnected the battery, did the twisting of the throttle to reset the sensors.... and Bingo.... all was back working correctly????
Needless to say, i took the bike into my dealer (balderstons) but was told they could see no problems within the fault codes, but the battery was showing as only half charged???? (the bike had been back on the optimate overnight between the problem and getting to the dealer, and was showing fully charged again)
Basically, i still have no idea what really went on, but the problem has not occurred since.
When i saw this thread, just seemed a few too many similarities to not be related!